美国三十年来: 超过100万女性被过度诊断为早期癌症

frank.Irvine

知名会员
VIP
注册
2011-09-15
消息
2,423
荣誉分数
114
声望点数
123


今天,2012年12月8日,纽约时报刊登了 Prof. H. Gilbert Welch (1)的文章,题为


<<Cancer Survivor or Victim of Overdiagnosis?>>

<<癌症幸存者,还是过度诊断的受害者?>>


http://cn.nytimes.com/article/opinion/2012/12/08/c08welch/dual/



"The harm of overdiagnosis shouldnót come as a surprise. Six years ago,
a long-term follow-up of a randomized trial showed that about one-quarter
of cancers detected by screening were overdiagnosed. And this study reflected
mammograms as used in the 1980s. Newer digital mammograms detect a lot more
abnormalities, and the estimates of overdiagnosis have risen commensurately:
now somewhere between a third and half of screen-detected cancers."

这数字要是真的,看来全信医生或者医院,是要不得呀! :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:


(1) Overdiagnosed: Making People Sick in the Pursuit of Health
ISBN-13: 978-0807021996 的作者。







 
什么是"过度诊断"?
 


我也不懂,也是 Google 的。

"Overdiagnosis is the diagnosis of "disease" that will never cause symptoms or death during a patient's lifetime.
Overdiagnosis is a side effect of testing for early forms of disease which may turn people into patients unnecessarily
and may lead to treatments that do no good and perhaps do harm."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overdiagnosis





 
误诊?

朋友,你们美国什么都是越大越好啊?
 


这文章让小朋友想起前年还是更早的时候,一个医生写了一篇关于身边好几位的医生他们是如何面对自己的绝症的。

那文章写得很好的,题目叫什么来的呢?! 想不起来啦,靠腰! 中年痴呆! :p :p :p :p 如果没记错的话那文章好像是

刊登在 Zocalo Public Square 上的。有人读过类似的文章吗?!


Anyway,那文章最触动小朋友的是,这帮大名顶顶的医生,当知道自己得了绝症后,是回家待着哟,

而不是上医院吃药、打针、做手术以求多活个一二年。因为他们对医院与医生,乃至整个医疗系统与

行业,都太清楚了。除了增加病人的痛苦,与及从中攫取病人的钱财外,病人所延续的一二年的生命

的代价,是一种折磨。





 
看来,从某种意义上说,是否可以说cancers survivers就是骗局呢?
 


朋友,你们美国什么都是越大越好啊?



:D :D :D :D

那是,母的,屁股大好生养;公的,肚子大像条牛,世界警察的标准身栽! :p :p :p :p :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :cool:



 
这数字要是真的,看来全信医生或者医院,是要不得呀! :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

你什么意思?西医就是科学,你懂不懂?你不信科学,还能信啥?也不怕CFC的科学家博士们砸死你。:mad::D:D
 
让我们站在更高的道德制高点上去!
 

让我们站在更高的道德制高点上去!



:D :D :D :D 得! 得! 得! 。。。小朋友不就过把嘴瘾嘛,得了,我把上面的话删了吧。


唏,C老爷,刚从文学城读到
<<乔布斯死亡真相:25岁肿瘤已在 受化学物质感染>>

http://www.wenxuecity.com/news/2012/12/09/2117319.html

原文是 <<Why Did Steve Jobs Die?>> November 2011 Volume 10 Issue 11

http://www.drmcdougall.com/misc/2011nl/nov/jobs.htm


要按 Dr. McDougall 这说法,2003年前的十多二十年,Jobs 早就"有病"啦,何以为他看病的医生们啥就没查出来呢?! :confused: :confused: :confused:






 
后退
顶部