尤勇批某天才钢琴家：他一闭眼作秀我就恶心

[superlover]

内地实力男星尤勇于近日做客《凤凰网-非常道》，与主持人何东进行一场真诚深入的谈话。

节选的文字实录：

　　尤勇：我对音乐的感觉又不一样，比如说咱们有两个天才的钢琴家有一个我就特别反感，有一个我就特别喜欢。

　　何东：谁?

　　尤勇：就不举名字了。有一个我就觉得他是在表演，他一到镜头来了以后他的眼睛就开始，我觉得他是表演，特别恶心，他不是真正的沉浸，他在作秀，尽管他很有名尽管他出场费很高，尽管所有人都说他特别棒，但我一点都不喜欢他。

　　何东：我是看他一场音乐会半场退席了。

　　尤勇：我就不能忍受他在弹钢琴的时候去那个做那种样子，好像他知道这个时候世界上人民都在看他，我需要表现出来我对音乐是理解得多么深刻，我对这个曲子的感受力是这样的，太傻了。

 

[superlover]

地球人都知道他说的是李云迪和郎朗。我对郎的感觉也是如此

 

[curiousbeaver]

内地实力男星尤勇于近日做客《凤凰网-非常道》，与主持人何东进行一场真诚深入的谈话。

节选的文字实录：

　　尤勇：我对音乐的感觉又不一样，比如说咱们有两个天才的钢琴家有一个我就特别反感，有一个我就特别喜欢。

　　何东：谁?

　　尤勇：就不举名字了。有一个我就觉得他是在表演，他一到镜头来了以后他的眼睛就开始，我觉得他是表演，特别恶心，他不是真正的沉浸，他在作秀，尽管他很有名尽管他出场费很高，尽管所有人都说他特别棒，但我一点都不喜欢他。

　　何东：我是看他一场音乐会半场退席了。

　　尤勇：我就不能忍受他在弹钢琴的时候去那个做那种样子，好像他知道这个时候世界上人民都在看他，我需要表现出来我对音乐是理解得多么深刻，我对这个曲子的感受力是这样的，太傻了。

then don't go to the concert, or listen to their performance, simple as that. why do they have to yell out to let everybody know? don't they show off themselves by saying that?

 

[superlover]

李云迪得过肖邦第1名，水平可不是郎能盖的，人家还老老实实去进修

 

[cvictor]

音乐会又不是看的，闭上眼睛就行。

 

[长夜未央]

then don't go to the concert, or listen to their performance, simple as that. why do they have to yell out to let everybody know? don't they show off themselves by saying that?

btw, 尤勇是那根葱

 

[ottawa_it_blue_collar]

怎么跟我的感觉一样。

 

[锐不可当的三]

then don't go to the concert, or listen to their performance, simple as that. why do they have to yell out to let everybody know? don't they show off themselves by saying that?

你都可以对尤勇的访谈、言论在此发表评论，为啥尤勇就不能把自己对朗朗的感觉阐述一下？
己之不欲，勿施于人，你是不是也该这么想想？你都能说尤勇，为啥尤勇不可说朗朗？
为什么尤勇阐述一下自己的观点就成了Show Off了呢？ 为什么要以己度人，妄自揣多他人的意图呢？

 

[锐不可当的三]

btw, 尤勇是那根葱

BTW，你又蒜哪跟葱？

 

[curiousbeaver]

你都可以对尤勇的访谈、言论在此发表评论，为啥尤勇就不能把自己对朗朗的感觉阐述一下？
己之不欲，勿施于人，你是不是也该这么想想？你都能说尤勇，为啥尤勇不可说朗朗？
为什么尤勇阐述一下自己的观点就成了Show Off了呢？ 为什么要以己度人，妄自揣多他人的意图呢？

did i say he CANNOT say something about others? everybody is entitled to his/her ideas, so are you and I. it is my opinion that he is showing off, your illogical questions do not construct a valid argument for debate.

 

[fmart.ca]

尤勇可以不喜欢某个人，他有这个权利，但那只是他个人的感觉。别人和可以不喜欢他。

 

[锐不可当的三]

did i say he CANNOT say something about others? everybody is entitled to his/her ideas, so are you and I. it is my opinion that he is showing off, your illogical questions do not construct a valid argument for debate.

那你解释下”Why do they have to yell out？“ 是什么意思吧？
人家尤勇没有 have to， 就是want to。

我的观点也很清楚。 你说他Showing off 就是你主观臆断，妄加猜度。你评论尤勇的所有论点 包括showing off ，放在你身上是同样适用的。 我说的有什么问题吗？
我的观点不是你不可以评论尤勇的言论。我说你的观点前后矛盾，你在指责别人的同时却自己也在做同样的事，你不懂吗？

 

[curiousbeaver]

那你解释下”Why do they have to yell out？“ 是什么意思吧？
人家尤勇没有 have to， 就是want to。

我的观点也很清楚。 你说他Showing off 就是你主观臆断，妄加猜度。你评论尤勇的所有论点 包括showing off ，放在你身上是同样适用的。 我说的有什么问题吗？
我的观点不是你不可以评论尤勇的言论。我说你的观点前后矛盾，你在指责别人的同时却自己也在做同样的事，你不懂吗？

i don't usually explain the argument i used in discussion but felt in this case i have to enlighten some people

the rhetorical question i used was to bring in a valid argument that the actor "has to" express his opinion on a public show and why is that? my opinion is it is his job to attract attentions to gain financial benefit. if it is not a "yell out" on a well established channel, would you and I who are over thousands of miles away have heard of him? the "have to" i used here emphasized certainty and a little bit necessity for the actor. the second rhetorical question only asserted the point that while he is questioning Lang lang's stage style to be show-off, his show-off is examined against by his very own criteria.

now back to your questions. in fact, i find your argument rather indirectly proved my point by using my argument if not invalid. you did not bring in anything new for readers to think about. instead, you misread my post, did not establish any valid points and your inconsistency cost you your whole post a waste.

you seemed to be a smart guy, but your lack of patience and respect to others makes you only a rude insulter rather than a debater.