CBC "The National" 今晚播出对林俊父母的专访

[买卖楼]

很多评论基本观点是：CBC不该搞这次采访；林的父母不该接受采访。

大多数人的评论是不应把这事与加拿大的治安情况相联系。是个案。这种杀人狂在哪国（包括中国大陆）都可能有。好像没有评“CBC该不该搞这次采访；林的父母该不该接受采访”。

 

[ccc]

大多数人的评论是不应把这事与加拿大的治安情况相联系。是个案。这种杀人狂在哪国（包括中国大陆）都可能有。好像没有评“CBC该不该搞这次采访；林的父母该不该接受采访”。

I said: 很多评论基本观点是

You said: 大多数人的评论

So?

 

[GYGY]

我也和儿子一起看了，看到林妈妈哭的时候真让人心碎，我忍不住对儿子说了句：ai,孩子就是父母的一切啊。。
林妈妈说了多次（大意）：觉得加拿大是个安全的地方，可孩子。。。儿子的观点是：加拿大的确是个安全的地方，至于个案。。
我想林妈妈不是怪加拿大什么，就是表达一 种对意外的难以接受吧。。

 

[ccc]

....。好像没有评“CBC该不该搞这次采访；林的父母该不该接受采访”。

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/story/2012/07/16/jun-lin-murder-parents-grief-china.html

Busterstandard
2012/07/17
at 8:39 AM ET
Why doesn't the media leave this family alone?

tarteflambestandard
2012/07/17
at 8:14 AM ET
I am appalled at the CBC's lascivious pursuit of this couple and its exploitation of their grief. There is no news value, no moral justification for story _ only an attempt to boost reputations and ratings in a slow season.

_Oh-Puhlease_standard
2012/07/17
at 1:07 AM ET
I don't think this interview needed to be done. What realistically was hoped that it could accomplish?

None of us could hope to fully understand the pain the parents must be feeling.-with the possible exception of the parents of the young man murdered on a Bus.........

I also am very concerned that the perception of fact s yet to be determined in OUR legal system is being taken for granted.

Magnotta is innocent until proven guilty. The remains of the victim have not yet been proven to be authentic.

We can now add to the parents as victims- the presumption of innocence, trial by media, and the hysteria and draconian legal revisions that will inevitably happen by the Federal government, who uses these types of cases to set policy.

CBC I am normally a big supporter. But you guys blew it in this case. This interview was not needed, and in my respectful opinion did nothing but make matters worse.


CeeDeeEnnstandard
2012/07/16
at 10:53 PM ET
once again, CBC has unfortunately lowered its standards to the Maury Povich level.. Mark kelly exclusive interview? Sorry, this is mere sensationalist exploitation.

What do we see, what do we learn,? Parents grief? As it would be in any death of a child,..its always tragic for the parents. Do we need to see that? As if we didnt know it? Ask any parent who has lost a child, whether to disease, accident, or horrific death..does it matter how? its =always= a terrible terrible loss to the parents.

I feel deep sorrow for the parents for the horrific killing of their son., but I sure didnt need this interview for that, the facts speak for themselves..and so to seek ratings based on these unfortunate people's persnoal greif and tragedy? pretty low class CBC, pretty cheap Mr Kelly.

Someone's judgement at the CBC really went downhill on this. Its what happens when you fire, or early retire all the experienced old hands, those with judgement, and replace them with cheap J-school students who rise up the ranks never having learned from the long gone old-hands.

muggsystandard
2012/07/16
at 10:43 PM ET
Making a public spectacle of the grief of the Lin family by CBC is a complete disgrace. The family should not have been put on display in this manner. Has the CBC no respect for the greif and privacy needed at this time. Shame ,shame ,shame, on the CBC.

jsmelsstandard
2012/07/16
at 10:21 PM ET
Shame on CBC stooping to sensationalistic standards of US networks. This is an blatant ratings grab and self-serving for the once great TV news institution.
Wheres the interview with the parents of child killed be the drunk driver, or the mother lost to her family in one of the many car accidents occurring everyday across Canada. CBC should be ashamed. I have been watching the network for over 40 years and finally they have bottomed out. At least Mansbridge did not get mixed up in this.

GillesF9979standard
2012/07/16
at 9:15 PM ET
CBC needs to up it's standards. I learned nothing from this article.

This article exploits this woman's grief. It is sensationalism and continues the slide down to american-style Fear-mongering media standards

And what is the upside ? Does it tell us anything important ? It's obvious this woman's view of Canada has been altered.

Aces Highstandard
2012/07/16
at 7:57 PM ET
CBC has sunk to new lows with this story I feel deep saddness for Jun Lin's family, but this interview was not about a family's grief and loss. It is exploitation of those feelings to make a cheap political statement. Shame that our tax dollars go to fund this nationalistic crap.

700kotchistandard
2012/07/16
at 7:24 PM ET
Congratulations CBC. You've now stooped lower than Fox News and CNN. Hope you're very proud.

Mountebankstandard
2012/07/16
at 7:06 PM ET
This story and the idea behind it are an embarrassment. What did you folks think Lin's mom would say?
CBC's 'B' team has contrived a cheap, summer story out of the obvious sincerity of a grieving mother.

Anneliesstandard
2012/07/16
at 7:05 PM ET
Shame on you CBC. Why are you using these people's misery in order to gain viewers?
These are grieving parents who don't need the sensation seeking media or us, the viewer, to interfere in their time of sadness. Leave them alone, respect their feelings instead of coming in with cameras and microphones.

Greekherostandard
2012/07/16
at 6:57 PM ET
Is there any respect for a family's privacy in such tragic situations that the media will honour any more?
Well done, as usual, CBC editors and well done, lazy reporter.

 

[买卖楼]

共251条评论

 

[ccc]

共251条评论

....。好像没有评“CBC该不该搞这次采访；林的父母该不该接受采访”。

So, yes or no?

 

[买卖楼]

So, yes or no?

没有数！ 个人认为同情林氏夫妻。同情他们想要看到凶手得到审判的心情，但长期在蒙城住着，对他们的身体不利。

搞不搞电视谈话，对案情审判无影响！

 

[miaomiao2012]

没有数！ 个人认为同情林氏夫妻。同情他们想要看到凶手得到审判的心情，但长期在蒙城住着，对他们的身体不利。

搞不搞电视谈话，对案情审判无影响！

等审判干嘛啊,也没有死刑,看着心里更气

他们不是有那么多捐款了嘛,直接花些钱把凶手直接做掉好了~~~

 

[CanMa2011]

这是在加国发生的恶性时间，谁都知道林不该被杀。加国人的反应是＂我知道了，别再说啦！＂就如同你家儿子打了人，你觉得很丢人，人家再找上门，更没脸面了。
－ 所以评论会是这种基调。但不等于说它就是有理的。

 

[ccc]

没有数！ 个人认为同情林氏夫妻。同情他们想要看到凶手得到审判的心情，但长期在蒙城住着，对他们的身体不利。

搞不搞电视谈话，对案情审判无影响！

不需要数吧。

是在说这个么？中国人什么时候能学会坦诚一点呢。

 

[TIFF]

不知道庭审时这老两口能不能，会不会来，俺脚得人家这提前放这儿个victim impact statement，咋列么。
。。。

这是在加国发生的恶性时间，谁都知道林不该被杀。加国人的反应是＂我知道了，别再说啦！＂就如同你家儿子打了人，你觉得很丢人，人家再找上门，更没脸面了。
－ 所以评论会是这种基调。但不等于说它就是有理的。

就是， 咋列么。

这是人家父母的真实感受，咋了还不让说实话了？竟然还有人责备人家父母不理性，我呸！虚伪透顶。还自诩“宽容的国度”呢。

 

[买卖楼]

不需要数吧。

是在说这个么？中国人什么时候能学会坦诚一点呢。

要区分支持CBC和林家和反对的，当然要数一数。

放了电视，找陪审团的成员较难。这就是为什么加人一般不会急于上电视。

 

[ccc]

要区分支持CBC和林家和反对的，当然要数一数。

放了电视，找陪审团的成员较难。这就是为什么加人一般不会急于上电视。

我们有异议、讨论的是：

很多评论基本观点是：CBC不该搞这次采访；林的父母不该接受采访。

大多数人的评论是不应把这事与加拿大的治安情况相联系。是个案。这种杀人狂在哪国（包括中国大陆）都可能有。好像没有评“CBC该不该搞这次采访；林的父母该不该接受采访”。

我引用了一些CBC网站的评论，试图佐证有那样的评论。

 

[苦逼热狗]

CBC不应该在开庭之前播这期节目

 

[ccc]

CBC不应该在开庭之前播这期节目

林的父母应该拒绝采访。

另外，２个多小时谈这些多痛苦啊!