那英组好声音正在直播

[James]

你要拔到那样的高度，我觉得毛主席更应该上榜.

没有拔到那高度。崔健是真把自己唱上去了。

 

[mimi_ge]

我大学寝室有个正宗摇滚迷，穷鬼一个，省吃简用，买卡口带，只听纯摇滚。从头摇到脚的那种。

 

[James]

那是因为老崔的很多歌词带有政治意味。



齐秦是台湾人，那时候白色恐怖已经结束，所以没那么多感触。



论曲调的好听度及传播度，齐秦胜过老崔。但歌词没老崔震感。

歌好不好听有时和政治有关系，但绝大多数的时候没关系。

 

[我爱坐公车]

我大学寝室有个正宗摇滚迷，穷鬼一个，省吃简用，买卡口带，只听纯摇滚。从头摇到脚的那种。

只听重金属的是真牛,认识人中有两个就是那样，当然是当时，现在不是了.

 

[我爱坐公车]

温习一下.

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fvPpAPIIZyo[/media]

 

[我爱坐公车]

歌好不好听有时和政治有关系，但绝大多数的时候没关系。

我是听了很多西方摇滚后才听到崔健的,当时不明白为什么那么多人迷他,现在有点明白了.

 

[gingerale]

我是汪峰的粉，但不得不承认，那个梁博唱汪的歌比汪峰演绎得也许更到位（汪峰处理高音的部分过于“沧桑”）。

同意，梁博唱得非常有感觉。象吟唱自己的心声似的，有书卷气。他要是能自己写歌就真好了。很关注他，算这场的惊喜了。年轻，是权的学生。 这些选手，很多都是科班的，包括前面很多人不以为然的李多沫。

汪峰是伪摇滚?那是不是只有重金属才算摇滚？soft rock呢？beyond是不是也是伪摇滚？beatles还有《yesterday》这样的歌呢。还齐秦更rock，。为啥呀？他的声音好得象乐器，但摇滚？他的精神气质不觉得是。:blink:

黄勇，太放，完全没有回味的余地，我说得刻薄点，酒吧唱法。:blowzy:。

我个人觉得汪峰的问题是词太直白，不够美。但比起硬拼凑的华丽莫名其妙款，我还是更喜欢他的直接有力。

多亮的声音是我很喜欢的，但这场前面唱得平平，选歌问题吧。让我对汪的制作能力有点疑问。也许汪不够用心？:blink:

张纬，和莫愁有类似，人来疯型，有表演欲，在舞台上光芒四射，加分。最后那首英文歌唱得不怎么样。

张赫宣，喜欢的TZ能解解惑么？强在哪？:blowzy::blink:

 

[colonel]

革命歌曲

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5Sh1Riw0_k[/media]

 

[wuwei]

可能个人感觉也有关系,我就特迷Pink Floyd，第一次听就喜欢，也不知道为什么.

就是Pink Floyd使我觉得他们也挺政治挂帅的，记得那时他们有一首关于64的歌, 叫watching TV，从64扯到台湾，这是歌词自己看吧：We were watching T.V.
Watching T.V.
We were Watching T.V.
Watching T.V.
In Tiananmen Square
Lost my baby there
My yellow rose
In her bloodstained clothes
She was a short order pastry chef
In a Dim Sum dive on the Yangtze tideway
She had shiny hair
She was the daughter of an engineer
Won't you shed a tear
For my yellow rose
My yellow rose
In her bloodstained clothes
She had perfect breasts
She had high hopes
She had almond eyes
She had yellow thighs
She was a student of philosophy
Won't you grieve with me
For my yellow rose
Shed a tear
For her bloodstained clothes
She had shiny hair
She had perfect breasts
She had high hopes
She had almond eyes
She had yellow thighs
She was the daughter of an engineer
So get out your pistols
Get out your stones
Get out your knives
Cut them to the bone
They are the lackeys of the grocer's machine
They built the dark satanic mills
That manufacture hell on earth
They bought the front row seats on Calvary
They are irrelevant to me
But I grieve for my sister
People of China
Do not forget do not forget
The children who died for you
Long live the Republic
Did we do anything after this
I've a feeling we did
We were watching T.V.
Watching T.V.
We were watching T.V.
Watching T.V.
She wore a white bandanna that said
Freedom now
She thought the Great Wall of China
Would come tumbling down
She was a student
Her father was an engineer
Won't you shed a tear
For my yellow rose
My yellow rose
In her bloodstained clothes
Her grandpa fought old Chiang Kai-shek
That no-good low-down dirty rat
Who used to order his troops
To fire on the women and children
Imagine that imagine that
And in the spring of '48
Mao Tse-tung got quite irate
And he kicked that old dictator Chiang
Out of the state of China
Chiang Kai-shek came down in Formosa
And they armed the island of Quemoy
And the shells were flying across the China Sea
And they turned Formosa into a shoe factory
Called Taiwan
And she is different from Cro-Magnon man
She's different from Anne Boleyn
She is different from the Rosenbergs
And from the unknown Jew
She is different from the unknown Nicaraguan
Half superstar half victim
She's a victor star conceptually new
And she is different from the Dodo
And from the Kankanbono
She is different from the Aztec
And from the Cherokee
She's everybody's sister
She's symbolic of our failure
She's the one in fifty million
Who can help us to be free
Because she died on T.V.
And I grieve for my sister

 

[James]

我是听了很多西方摇滚后才听到崔健的,当时不明白为什么那么多人迷他,现在有点明白了.

你可能不知道，我们就是听着他的歌去抗争的。

 

[mimi_ge]

同意，梁博唱得非常有感觉。象吟唱自己的心声似的，有书卷气。他要是能自己写歌就真好了。很关注他，算这场的惊喜了。年轻，是权的学生。 这些选手，很多都是科班的，包括前面很多人不以为然的李多沫。



汪峰是伪摇滚?那是不是只有重金属才算摇滚？soft rock呢？beyond是不是也是伪摇滚？beatles还有《yesterday》这样的歌呢。还齐秦更rock，。为啥呀？他的声音好得象乐器，但摇滚？他的精神气质不觉得是。:blink:



黄勇，太放，完全没有回味的余地，我说得刻薄点，酒吧唱法。:blowzy:。



我个人觉得汪峰的问题是词太直白，不够美。但比起硬拼凑的华丽莫名其妙款，我还是更喜欢他的直接有力。



多亮的声音是我很喜欢的，但这场前面唱得平平，选歌问题吧。让我对汪的制作能力有点疑问。也许汪不够用心？:blink:



张纬，和莫愁有类似，人来疯型，有表演欲，在舞台上光芒四射，加分。最后那首英文歌唱得不怎么样。



张赫宣，喜欢的TZ能解解惑么？强在哪？:blowzy::blink:

梁声音唱法像张楚，我喜欢。

黄已经淘汰，不谈。

多亮不会红，太普通。

张纬除了高音，乐感其实并不好，把jackson的歌唱成那副吊样，我倒。

张赫宣为啥我看好呢，很简单，声音将破未破，这是高手中的高手，而且此人乐感极佳，大概是声乐老师的缘故吧。

他应该会到最后。

 

[wuwei]

我是听了很多西方摇滚后才听到崔健的,当时不明白为什么那么多人迷他,现在有点明白了.

表面上，相比西方的，崔健的东西就还是太简单规矩了，但是贵在他的骨子里的东西，这事秤骨先生秤过的

 

[gingerale]

没有拔到那高度。崔健是真把自己唱上去了。

王朔曾经聊过，军队大院的没落。说大院的人曾经是走在社会最前列的，比如老崔，接触世界音乐早，他的摇滚走在社会最前面，别人都没见过。后来就是平民社会了，军队特权越来越少。我记得他有本小说《许爷》，本意可能是嘲讽人的麻木和类似王小波说的密室SM心态的，但我看完，更讨厌军队大院子弟那高高在上的心态。
可能这是我不那么fan老崔的潜意识？:blink::blowzy:

不过，必须承认，老崔的有几首歌词太牛了，尤其是《一块红布》，
曲子，也不错，现在看稍微简单了点，但还是很强的。

 

[James]

张纬除了高音，乐感其实并不好，把jackson的歌唱成那副吊样，我倒。

说他唱的是MJ的歌，我整个晕头转向。哪里有半点MJ的味道？

 

[我爱坐公车]

就是Pink Floyd使我觉得他们也挺政治挂帅的，记得那时他们有一首关于64的歌, 叫watching TV，从64扯到台湾，这是歌词自己看吧：We were watching T.V.
Watching T.V.
We were Watching T.V.
Watching T.V.
In Tiananmen Square
Lost my baby there
My yellow rose
In her bloodstained clothes
She was a short order pastry chef
In a Dim Sum dive on the Yangtze tideway
She had shiny hair
She was the daughter of an engineer
Won't you shed a tear
For my yellow rose
My yellow rose
In her bloodstained clothes
She had perfect breasts
She had high hopes
She had almond eyes
She had yellow thighs
She was a student of philosophy
Won't you grieve with me
For my yellow rose
Shed a tear
For her bloodstained clothes
She had shiny hair
She had perfect breasts
She had high hopes
She had almond eyes
She had yellow thighs
She was the daughter of an engineer
So get out your pistols
Get out your stones
Get out your knives
Cut them to the bone
They are the lackeys of the grocer's machine
They built the dark satanic mills
That manufacture hell on earth
They bought the front row seats on Calvary
They are irrelevant to me
But I grieve for my sister
People of China
Do not forget do not forget
The children who died for you
Long live the Republic
Did we do anything after this
I've a feeling we did
We were watching T.V.
Watching T.V.
We were watching T.V.
Watching T.V.
She wore a white bandanna that said
Freedom now
She thought the Great Wall of China
Would come tumbling down
She was a student
Her father was an engineer
Won't you shed a tear
For my yellow rose
My yellow rose
In her bloodstained clothes
Her grandpa fought old Chiang Kai-shek
That no-good low-down dirty rat
Who used to order his troops
To fire on the women and children
Imagine that imagine that
And in the spring of '48
Mao Tse-tung got quite irate
And he kicked that old dictator Chiang
Out of the state of China
Chiang Kai-shek came down in Formosa
And they armed the island of Quemoy
And the shells were flying across the China Sea
And they turned Formosa into a shoe factory
Called Taiwan
And she is different from Cro-Magnon man
She's different from Anne Boleyn
She is different from the Rosenbergs
And from the unknown Jew
She is different from the unknown Nicaraguan
Half superstar half victim
She's a victor star conceptually new
And she is different from the Dodo
And from the Kankanbono
She is different from the Aztec
And from the Cherokee
She's everybody's sister
She's symbolic of our failure
She's the one in fifty million
Who can help us to be free
Because she died on T.V.
And I grieve for my sister

哥门,政治挂帅是啥都和政治挂钩吧？他们有吗？那东西主要是中国那几代人的特点。摇滚歌手把热点事情写进歌里很多的,可这不应该算是政治挂帅吧？.