问一个转移股票的问题。

[wyandywja]

Are you sure you can have $10 C loss?

你想要多少？

 

[wyandywja]

Things happen in this trade:



1) t4rsp tax on 500 (whatever your marginal tax rate is):



不完全对。税是这么计算的：
0-5000： 10％
500.01-15000：20％
＞15000： 30％

税务局会在年底根据你的收入去调节这些税。

 

[lightyear]

你想要多少？

Your reply seams you can have C loss for sure. However, I doubt it unless you did it and taxman did not knock at your door. I guess it could fall in the selling and buying the same stock within 30 days, which no C loss apply.

It should be clear the difference between withholding tax and marginal income tax in the first place.

 

[dkwan]

agree

Things happen in this trade:







1) t4rsp tax on 500 (whatever your marginal tax rate is):







不完全对。税是这么计算的：

0-5000： 10％

500.01-15000：20％

＞15000： 30％



税务局会在年底根据你的收入去调节这些税。

 

[wyandywja]

Your reply seams you can have C loss for sure. However, I doubt it unless you did it and taxman did not knock at your door. I guess it could fall in the selling and buying the same stock within 30 days, which no C loss apply.



It should be clear the difference between withholding tax and marginal income tax in the first place.

我想我们谈的是２个问题。你说的是superficial loss的问题，是税务问题，我不是税务专家，我不知道该怎么回答这个问题；我说的是把股票转移到免税帐户如何计算capital gain 或者 capital loss的问题。是否能申报capital loss，得问税务专家。

 

[lightyear]

我想我们谈的是２个问题。你说的是superficial loss的问题，是税务问题，我不是税务专家，我不知道该怎么回答这个问题；我说的是把股票转移到免税帐户如何计算capital gain 或者 capital loss的问题。是否能申报capital loss，得问税务专家。

Terms of capital gain and capital loss always refers to tax implication. I don't think anybody here want to discuss elementary math.

 

[笨妈笨爸]

接着问一下：如果我一两年内要买房子，第一次那种，是不是最好转到RRSP，而不是TFSA？这样既可以抵消我的收入税，又可以在买房子的时候取出来。

 

[wyandywja]

接着问一下：如果我一两年内要买房子，第一次那种，是不是最好转到RRSP，而不是TFSA？这样既可以抵消我的收入税，又可以在买房子的时候取出来。

应该是。