为什么“哈哈“和为什么唯恐天下不乱。
- 主题发起人 next123
- 开始时间
1 我真不认为魁省是否独立是魁省自己的事，就象我不认为台湾是否独立是台湾自己的事一样。因为哪怕只从逻辑上讲，如果认为“魁省是否独立是魁省自己的事” ，“台湾是否独立是台湾自己的事” ，那么其潜前提是：魁省与加拿大(或台湾与中国)是两个独立的主体，至少是处于对等地位，而历史和现实却是主权国家所属省份与主权国家的关系，显然是包容和从属关系。按你的逻辑，如果哪天安省要独立，也是安省自己的事了？你不会这样认为吧？
2 你说“加拿大人反对魁独的占多数” ，事实确实如此。不过既然你认为魁省是否独立是魁省自己的事，那是不是在说，魁省以外的加拿大人在其是否独立问题上最多只能起参考作用而非决定作用，否则便不是魁省自己的事了。问题是你接着说” 但没有人认为一旦魁独就要出兵“，这就令人费解了。我想你肯定知道当年的” 十月风波“，那可不是“没有人认为一旦魁独就要出兵” ，而是联邦政府已经做了他认为该做的事情，那可是兵临城下，军事管制啊。
当我跟别人探讨/辩论时，如果我的观点确实相对更客观或合理一些，当然希望能说服人家接受我的见解；反之也乐于接受别人的观点或修正自己的观点。毕竟兼听则明，闻过则喜才是。
在comefromchina的网友中，你来加拿大的时间之长可是数一数二的了，中加两边的情况好象都很熟，这也是愿意与你探讨这种问题的原因。说我“耿耿于怀” ，是不是言重了点儿？ 关于现在的话题我只跟你二帖，还又查了一遍那二帖的内容，实在找不处哪些内容/观点/暗示使你觉得我“耿耿于怀” 。能指点迷津吗？
oread
新手上路
- 注册
- 2002-01-24
- 消息
- 20,272
- 荣誉分数
- 16
- 声望点数
- 0
你说什么: My apologies, shouldn't have said that!
I welcome your discussion, however I don't think we could agree on it. I think it's totally up to the Quebecors as it should be totally up to the Ontarians if they decide to be an independent country. The rest of the provinces is only there for support, just like what happened in the last Quebec referendum in 1996. This is called democracy, perhaps not always the best solution for everthing, but that's the best we have so far.
As a mainlander, I absolutely HATE to see Taiwan go separated, but I respect the choice of the people of Taiwan. Unification should be a mutually beneficial deal, not something forced on them.
I welcome your discussion, however I don't think we could agree on it. I think it's totally up to the Quebecors as it should be totally up to the Ontarians if they decide to be an independent country. The rest of the provinces is only there for support, just like what happened in the last Quebec referendum in 1996. This is called democracy, perhaps not always the best solution for everthing, but that's the best we have so far.
As a mainlander, I absolutely HATE to see Taiwan go separated, but I respect the choice of the people of Taiwan. Unification should be a mutually beneficial deal, not something forced on them.
