加拿大移民部考虑大赦非法移民

[USD]

加拿大移民部考虑大赦非法移民

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2004年09月12日，来源：环球邮报

有报道说，加拿大自由党政府在考虑对至少1万名在加拿大生活和工作的非法移民实行大赦。

加拿大全国发行的报纸环球邮报是根据政府的一份内部文件作出上述报道的。

早在 2001 年的克里靖政府时代，移民部即已制定名为“特别措施”的非法劳工大赦计划，但后来因故未实施。来自联邦政府的内部消息称，因为非法劳工的问题越来越严重、地下经济活动也日益活跃，打黑工人数太过庞大之事，已到了非解决不可的地步，移民部才又旧事重提。

环球邮报说，自由党政府的移民部部长斯格罗女士正在考虑如何解决在加拿大打黑工的成千上万非法移民的问题。

 

[colonel]

do not

 

[fallleave]

upup

 

[abner]

不可能，这样做是对移民制度的挑战

1.移民制度是加拿大的立国之本

2.对非法打工者大赦，对合法进入加拿大的移民来说是极大的不公平

3.此例一出，变相鼓励偷渡行为

4.移民都是经过政府选择的（通过移民政策的调整），总体素质较有保证

5.本对非法打工者大赦，有可能增加社会的压力（就业，治安）

 

[colonel]

这样不公平，这里这么多人废了很大的劲才移民的，黑户也能轻松得到移民资格，那以后谁还从正道来，我倒是希望他们能清查遣返一批。

 

[datamine]

that is the only solution, not bad for Canada.

 

[阿童木]

It is true that this may seem as a reward to those "law-breakers." But it is seen by social-modest govenment like Liberal, as a "lesser" of other painful options such as fored repatriation or maintaining camps for those peole.

The flip side of this is:
(0) First of all, legal or not legal in this context of "right to stay" all depends on time and place. I.e. Lot of us (so-called legal ones) will NOT be able to stay legally, if Canada (a) is NOT an immigrant-friendly country like in most Europe or (b) not at its immigrant-friendly time in history like in pre-1950.

(1) Illegal labour usually depresses the condition for "legal low-end labour market" since illegal workers usually work in bad condition with very little pay. So to help the legal "low-end labour market", the solution is to bring all illegal ones to the open market and have them stick to Canadian labour law (e.g min salary and CPP). This is almost the same reason that western countries want China in WTO and Unions here want workers in China get more pay and the same labour protection.

(2) Lot of illegal labours are victim or low-level "foot soldiers" of the criminal activities. They either do not dare come out in open to report criminal activities or need to risk a lot to get some protection from crime boss to stay in Canada. So major crime syndicates often thrive at place where there are large illegal migrants body. So giving these "boat people" some right will help stem the domestic crime groups. This is almost the same logic that Liberal wants to legalize the pot.

(3) To sooth some conservative opinions here It does NOT happen all the time in Canada (I remember, to Chinese, last time was 10+ years ago after the event in Tiananmen.) It can be seen as a very very compassionate & humantarian move to those people and their family who may have gone thru alot in situation (1) & (2) for long long time.

To me, everyone deserves a chance, especially you are Chinese.

As long as they are (1) Chinese, (2) willing to call here home and (3) work hard to EARN a peacful live with rest of us in Canada, I am all for it!

 

[iami]

can't agree more. Even if I have status, but I'd like to call for a compassionate for those who worked hard in this country without status. They deserver this.

 

[badman]

最初由 iami 发布
can't agree more. Even if I have status, but I'd like to call for a compassionate for those who worked hard in this country without status. They deserver this.

大赦对新移民是有好处的，也对全体加拿大社会和工人有好处。只对业主或招黑工的老板没好处。

 

[lifeisfun]

最初由 datamine 发布
that is the only solution, not bad for Canada.

Yes, what else can the government do? Catch them all and deport them, if there are 10,000 of them as said in the article, the government will spend tens of thousands money in order to do that, not to say they don't have the force to do that.

The better way to reduce illegal immigrants is to enforce the customer and immigrantion at the airport and border, as well as change the refuge process. But for those already in here for years
by any means, I don't think there is any better but let them stay.

 

[赖昌星发言人]

这次特赦包不包括星哥呀？

他在加拿大是良民啊。

 

[阿童木]

Re: 这次特赦包不包括星哥呀？

最初由 赖昌星发言人 发布
他在加拿大是良民啊。

Obsolutely NO mercy to any criminal (does not matter where crime is done). We shall only give compassion to hard working ones.

Lai is disgusting beyond comprehension and an utter disgrace to all people from China.

 

[doccs2002]

最初由 badman 发布


大赦对新移民是有好处的，也对全体加拿大社会和工人有好处。只对业主或招黑工的老板没好处。

对新移民有嘛好处

 

[cccc]

......对非法打工者大赦，对合法进入加拿大的移民来说是极大的不公平

此例一出，变相鼓励偷渡行为
......


钱留下，人赶走。

 

[xuxu]

AGREE.

最初由 colonel 发布
这样不公平，这里这么多人废了很大的劲才移民的，黑户也能轻松得到移民资格，那以后谁还从正道来，我倒是希望他们能清查遣返一批。