谁能回答我一个关于政治的问题

中国娃娃

the one, the only
注册
2002-10-06
消息
1,669
荣誉分数
0
声望点数
0
Senate 和 the House of Commons谁大呢?
为什么Senate 不能initiate finacial legislation?
谢谢
 
The Candian Senate is a rubber stamp. It can only slow down a legislative process.

Please check the relavent webpages for more.
 
看了网站没看明白,才跑来这里问的
上面也没说谁大,只是说Senate possesses(我不知道这里应该理解成拥有,还有支配呢?) all the power of the house of commons, except initiating finacial legislation.
但是我看了立法的过程,又是先经过the house of commons,然后才到senate,那就说明是senate大咯?
在给我具体讲讲
 
Well, technically the Senate is higher. But it has little real power.

Similarly, the Canadian head of state is her Majesty. But she has no real power either.

I guess you are a social science student. You should check the Canadian Constitution for a clear answer.

Or go the library. I can remmeber all the details now.
 
最初由 绣花袄 发布
Senate 和 the House of Commons谁大呢?
为什么Senate 不能initiate finacial legislation?
谢谢

要问细节就得查GOOGLE了.
粗略地说还行.
SENATE是参议院, the House of Commons是众议院.
美英本是一家.
参院相当于上院, 众院相当于下院.
根据英国的权利法案,
立法权在下院, 即平民院.
美国作为一分枝,
自然也沿袭了其传统.
 
众议员(MP)由全国选举产生,拥有最多MP的党执政,党头既为总理(PM),现任外嘴总理既为执政党自由党的头。参议员(Senate)由总理指定。

一项法律(Bill)的产生必须在众参两院获大多数通过,最后由总督批准才能生效。
 
有的国家上院的席位是世袭的,下院的席位由普选产生。上院通常是贵族,下院大多是平民。不存在谁大谁小的问题,互相制衡而已。
 
骗人, 你问的不是政治问题, 是政治知识问题.
 
加拿大的Senate不是民选的,大部分是富人和社会名流,如果Senate能initiate finacial legislation,那咱小平民的日子就没法过了。比如,他们可以弄个bill,使收入越多,征税越少。
 
谢谢大家
基本懂了,有空再继续学习学习
 
The legislative Branch has as its primary function the creation of laws, through the enactment of legislation. Provincially, the legislative branch is the legislature of the province, variously termed the legislature, House of Assembly, or Provincially parliament. Nationally, the legislative branch is the parliament of Canada, comprised of the House the Commons and the Senate.

The enumerated classes of subjects over which exclusive legislative authority is given to the Parliament of Canada by Section 91 give it the right to regulate the banking industry. It is expressly given jurisdiction over "banking, incorporation of banks, and the issue of paper money. The provinces, on the other hand, are given jurisdiction over other, related, matters.

Historically, the Parliament of Canada had a legislative policy of trying to preserve the tradition of setting apart separate territory of each of the four pillars of the financial services industry. Of course, banks and banking are in federal jurisdiction, but any attempt to regulate and standardize the other three are complicated by provincial jurisdiction in these areas.So, in my point of view, the key pint here is not which one is bigger.:)
 
楼主的问题非常好,既然大家来到加拿大,就应该了解一下加拿大的宪政结构,看看和中国有什么区别,加拿大是总督 议会,中国是总书记 人大,再找找共同点,两国都有橡皮图章,加拿大是总督,中国是人大。

老夫也不是很清楚Senate到底有什么作用,因为从选举程序来看,加拿大的政权的基础是众议院,内阁部长也来自MP。
 
后退
顶部