渥太华两次上诉要求终止与RTG10亿/30年的阿蹄维护合同,最近达成协议,RTG承认违约,渥太华合同没终止,还又付了几百万

metropolis

本站元老
注册
2010-12-10
消息
8,173
荣誉分数
1,475
声望点数
323

最近法庭判决:渥太华无法从10亿美元的维护合同中撤出,渥太华已经同意支付从2019年9月到2022年底6500万欠款的一部分。和解协议细节大部分仍然保密。当时的市长Watson 和交通主管Manconi多次告诉公众,由于服务质量差,市里没有付款。​

渥太华于2020年3月由于一系列事故,2021年秋季由于出轨事故,两次上诉要求解除与RTG30年10亿元的维护合同。​

LRT settlement gives builders millions in back pay, keeps their contract​


Settlement also closes door on Ottawa leaving the 30-year maintenance contract​


Joanne Chianello · CBC News · Posted: Feb 06, 2023 4:00 AM EST | Last Updated: 6 hours ago
1675702360587.png

Crews work on a stalled LRT train near Lees station in January. The city has agreed to pay Rideau Transit Group millions of dollars in withheld maintenance payments as part of a new settlement, CBC has learned. (David Bates-Taillefer/CBC)
The City of Ottawa is retroactively paying the consortium that built the Confederation Line millions of dollars for maintaining the LRT network as far back as the start of service in 2019, CBC has learned.
The money is part of a settlement package between the city and Rideau Transit Group (RTG) that puts to rest a number of disputes, including disagreements over maintenance payments.
It could be a turning point in the often-fractious relationship, as it makes good on a key recommendation in the light rail public inquiry report which urged the two parties to repair their partnership.
However, most of the details of the settlement remain secret.
On a number of occasions over the troubled life of the east-west light rail line, city leaders — including former mayor Jim Watson and former transit boss John Manconi — told the public the city was not paying RTG for maintenance due to poor service.
Now, according to CBC sources familiar with the deal, the city has agreed to pay a portion of the $65 million withheld from RTG's maintenance arm from September 2019 to the end of 2022.

No getting out of $1B maintenance contract​

The consortium — comprised of SNC Lavalin, ACS Infrastructure and Ellis Don — has also made concessions in the settlement package, CBC has learned, including promising to hire about a dozen more people by spring to provide more service to the city.
A key part of the deal is that it puts to rest the issue of default, a legal term indicating the group of companies wasn't living up to its contract with the city.
Ottawa served RTG with two separate notices of default: one in March 2020 due to a litany of problems that arose after the Confederation Line's launch and one in the fall of 2021 connected to derailments.
The city escalated the notice over the derailments to court in December 2021, asking a judge to confirm the default — an official step needed in the process for breaking the 30-year maintenance contract.
That's all over now.
In a densely worded legal statement the two sides released 10 days ago, RTG acknowledged it had not lived up to the contract, ending the need to keep arguing the point in court. The statement also said the settlement "resolves" the city's notices of default against RTG.
That means even though RTG finally agreed it breached the contract after years of legal fighting, the city has in turn also agreed to no longer consider RTG in default, thus closing the door on getting out of the $1-billion maintenance contract.

。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。

 
最后编辑:
市里每月付RTG4-5百万维护费,30年维护合同被判无法终止,记者询问:合同是否有所改变,市里不予回答。

2021年8月发生车轴断裂事故,18月后,有关机构没有给出发生断裂的根本原因分析报告。

1675704936670.png

The axle of a Confederation Line train broke on Aug. 8, 2021, prompting an investigation by the Transportation Safety Board of Canada. Neither the board nor RTG have produced a root cause analysis, 18 months after the axle failure. (Alexander Behne/CBC)
 
我来解释一下目前LRT 的麻烦

非得出伤亡事故才能动大筋骨,要不然民众和政府都没有动力和勇气来进行变革。
另一方面,维护和运营者安全第一,为了保证不出伤亡事故,隔三差五就停车,很多情况可能根本就不需要停车。

这个就是囚徒困境,未来可能就一直这样运行,即不能彻底解决问题,又不能保证LRT流畅运行,提速更别想了。
 
最后编辑:
我来解释一下目前LRT 的麻烦

非得出伤亡事故才能动大筋骨,要不然民众和政府都没有动力和勇气来进行变革。
另一方面,维护和运营者安全第一,为了保证不出伤亡事故,隔三差五就停车,很多情况可能根本就不需要停车。

这个就是囚徒困境,未来可能就一直这样运行

赶紧把二期三期都停了吧
 
赶紧把二期三期都停了吧
相反,市里已经接受RTG 解决脱轨问题的计划,2025年初将开通的延长轻轨线路继续由 RTG 维护。

Instead, according to last month's statement, the city has accepted RTG's "rigorous plan to address the issues that led to the derailments" and is committed to the "sustainable resolution of these issues" on the light rail vehicles before the Confederation Line's eastern extension opens in early 2025.
 
相反,市里已经接受RTG 解决脱轨问题的计划,2025年初将开通的延长轻轨线路继续由 RTG 维护。

Instead, according to last month's statement, the city has accepted RTG's "rigorous plan to address the issues that led to the derailments" and is committed to the "sustainable resolution of these issues" on the light rail vehicles before the Confederation Line's eastern extension opens in early 2025.
走着瞧呗,看2023是不是继续”奸情出轨“
 
所有的问题都是ottawa的市政问题,
RTG的spec有问题,testing facility建筑不到位
astrom一点关系都没有
只能说市政府傻逼
 
不论是事故不断还是无法解除合同,都是市政府的责任。悲哀的是市政府没有人对这失败的项目负责。
 
不论是事故不断还是无法解除合同,都是市政府的责任。悲哀的是市政府没有人对这失败的项目负责。
有人负责又能如何?给你一个人, 许你拉到Lansdowne Park,公开凌迟3天。 剩下的骨肉让你拿回去炖汤。 这够意思了吧。

那又如何?LRT还是三天两头停开, 合同还是无法解除。
 
这事尼玛就是加拿大的耻辱,告诉国内的人,都要被别人笑掉大牙。。
 
后退
顶部