雅典奥运裁判恶行TOP10:匈黑哨永远钉上耻辱柱

大熊猫

Moderator
管理成员
VIP
注册
2002-01-16
消息
22,826
荣誉分数
127
声望点数
243
  新浪体育讯 经过百年多历程的奥运会已经成为一个现代竞技体育的殿堂,她倡导更高、更快、更强、她呼唤公平、公正,同时她也传递着奋斗、和平、团结。因此,奥运不仅仅意味着竞争,也充满了快乐。尽管比赛还在进行,我们不否认这是一届精彩奥运会,美轮美奂的开幕式展现了源远流长的希腊文化,不断被刷新的奥运记录也展现了人类不断向极限发起冲击。

  但正是在这次快乐的盛会中,却屡屡出现让人作呕的、玷污寄托人类理想圣殿的行为。一些运动员以身试法作弊获得名次固然让人不齿,但一些裁判有意或无意的表现更让人唾弃。场外硝烟未断,黑衣法官竟然又充当了场内的“发起者”。在我们清楚地一次次看到了他们的“表演”,也一次次看到了英雄们委屈、无辜和无助的脸庞。

  十、 匈牙利黑哨被永远钉在耻辱柱

  尽管希达西已被遣送回国,但中国剑迷依旧不会原谅他,。除了意大利人拙劣的表演,裁判希达西一次次讨好般的误判让中国三剑客与近乎到手的金牌擦身而过。尽管国际剑协主席承认这次男花团体决赛执法是“耻辱”,但这已无法让金牌“失而复得”。不过,意大利人尽管抢走了这枚已一文不值金牌,但我们的三剑客却赢得了真正的尊重!

  九、庸裁起评分搞错夺走韩国金牌

  由于三名技术官员的失误,所以原本属于韩国选手梁泰荣的男子体操全能金牌竟然旁落到了美国人哈姆的手中。愚蠢的裁判竟然将梁泰荣本该10分的起评分搞错,从而“帮助”哈姆夺冠,而梁泰荣仅得到铜牌。韩国代表团也表示正在搜集比赛录像资料准备向体育仲裁法庭上诉,用实际行动为梁泰荣讨回公道,他们为维权而坚持不懈的精神确实让人钦佩。

  八、涅莫夫征服了观众受害于裁判

  同样是一场体操比赛,在男子体操单杠比赛中出现了令人震惊而感动的一幕:28岁的俄罗斯老将涅莫夫第三个出场,他在杠上一共完成了直体特卡切夫、分体特卡切夫、京格尔空翻、团身后空翻2周等连续6个空翻和腾越,非常精彩,只是落地往前跨了一步。他征服了观众,但是裁判只给了他9.725分!此刻,体操史上少有的情况出现了:全场观众愤怒着,他们全都站立起来,报以持久而响亮的嘘声,比赛不得不被打断。

  七、佩尔索仰泳金牌缘何失而复得

  在20日进行的男子200米仰泳决赛中,率先到达终点的佩尔索发现大屏幕上自己的成绩竟然被取消,但佩尔索只是虚惊了一场,国际游联技术委员会经过一番手忙脚乱的研究,最终决定把金牌“还”给佩尔索。但坚持不改初衷的法国裁判卡登却被剥夺了资格,体育馆顿时嘘声一片。事实上,通过录像可以清晰看到,佩尔索在150米转体时双脚确实没有碰到池壁,按规则其成绩应该无效。

  六、谭雪本可续写“栾菊杰”神话

  8月17日在谭雪对美国萨格尼斯的决赛中,开局白俄罗斯裁判出现了严重失误,有两剑判错,本来是谭雪刺中了萨格尼斯,裁判却将分判给了对手。赛后雅典奥运裁委会官员亲口向中国击剑队副领队赵春生承认:确实有两个判罚是错误的,并对此表示遗憾,但结果已经不能更改。明明是谭雪刺中对手却判对手得分。还有两剑应该判无效,因为两人同时刺中对手,双方均不能得分,而这样算下来话两人正好是11比11。

  五、李卓丢掉原本“最稳当”的金牌

  女子48公斤级举重的金牌赛前一直被当成“中国队最稳当的金牌”。在抓举比赛的第三次试举中,李卓因为胳膊肘后挺过肩膀而得到两盏红灯一盏白灯被判无效。由于这一判罚,李卓的抓举成绩落后对手泰兰5公斤多。而在稍后对手泰兰第三次试举时右肘有明显的弯曲,三个裁判却给出两盏白灯一盏红灯通过。赛后李卓指出如果裁判按照判自己95公斤这么严格来判,泰兰也是失败的。

  四、昏哨摇摆不定“大耍”德国马术

  得而复失、失而复得、再得而复失,德国的奖牌榜被两块马术金牌整得太惨。德国人豪伊在比赛中两次越过起跑线,在法国人提出上诉后,豪伊也提出上诉,最终要回了金牌。但参赛的法国、英国和美国联合向国际仲裁法庭提起上诉。最终国际体育仲裁法庭作出最终裁决,,法国夺回了团体赛冠军,个人金牌交给了英国选手劳的手中。德国的金牌也不得不减少了两枚。

  三、是谁让冰美人的谢幕未能完美?

  拥有修长身材、冷峻面庞的霍尔金娜是名副其实的冰美人,不过她却未能在体操生涯的最后一站获得期待已久的全能金牌。在接受俄罗斯媒体采访时,霍尔金娜宣称是裁判抢走了她的金牌。当女子全能的比赛中,霍尔金娜高低杠项目中的优美动作竟然只获得了9.462分。这位冰美人不完美的不得不接受这样的结局,尽管她表示:我做好了每个动作,但裁判就是不想给我高分。

  二、日本女足也遭遇美国强势冲击

  美国女足胜日本队本来是很正常的事,但是日本队显然显得不服,因为他们觉得美国队胜之不武。而从电视画面来看,在这场比赛中,美国进第二球之前,至少有五名队员有很明显的越位嫌疑,尽管日本队竭力抗议,但当值主裁判和助理裁判都没做任何表示,任由博克斯和瓦姆巴奇把日本门将耍个够后进球。看来不管是谁,和美国队发生争议时必定是“失败者”,裁判只是摆设。

  一、美国“特权”渗透到每个角落

  在田径女子七项全能200米比赛,一名美国选手在发令枪响的同时举起手臂申请暂停,但举手已明显晚了,所有的选手都冲了出去,惟独她没有动弹。结果按照规则,她没有取得200米跑的成绩。但在一番痛哭流涕不知是何内容的倾诉后,这名美国选手竟然被允许参加下一组的比赛。她的全能道路得以延续下去。究竟是眼泪的力量有这么大还是因为别的因素?

  纵观这些错误也好、失误也罢,本届雅典奥运会上如此多引起争议的判罚反映了裁判的执法水平问题。作为消除一切歧视,体现人类和平盛会的奥运会,公平、公正永远是奥林匹克精神的基石。但这一系列的事实的存在让我们对奥林匹克这片净土与否打上问号,尤其是作为执法者的裁判,由他们导致的这些错判、误判给原本可以更加精彩的雅典奥运抹上肮脏、龌龊的污点。
 
Artistic Gymnastics is a bit like Figure Skating now. Too much politics involved in this sport. :mad::mad:
 
I was told to raise gymnast's score, Canadian judge reveals
- 'I didn't have a choice,' he says - Top official made 'emphatic' request as angry crowd roared

Randy Boswell
The Ottawa Citizen; with files from The Calgary Herald


Thursday, August 26, 2004



CREDIT: GRACE CHIU, GYMNASTICS CANADA
Canadian gymnastics judge Chris Grabowecky is back home in Calgary after an 'extremely stressful' stint at the Olympics. He said he was pressured by a top gymnastics official to change the mark he gave to a Russian after the crowd erupted in anger and wouldn’t be quiet.

ATHENS - A Canadian gymnastics judge at the centre of one of the most controversial episodes of the Olympic Games says the competition's senior official "emphatically" urged him to upgrade his scoring of a popular Russian's high-bar routine as an angry crowd roared its disapproval of a lower mark.

Chris Grabowecky, who returned to Calgary on Tuesday after what he called an "extremely stressful" judging assignment at the Athens Games, says he and Malaysian judge Kin Kin Teh were pressured by Adrian Stoica, technical director of the International Gymnastics Federation, to make the scoring changes as mayhem threatened to take hold of the Olympic Indoor Hall on Monday night.

Mr. Grabowecky says he doesn't know if the change was ordered to appease the mob. But nearly everyone who witnessed the event has concluded that was the case.

The higher marks were enough to quell the chaos, and to send U.S. coach Miles Avery into a fit. "I certainly hope some of you get a chance to talk to FIG," he said afterwards to reporters, referring to the sport's governing body. "And ask why would the scores change after the crowd went wild? Is that all it takes to get a higher score?"

American gymnast Paul Hamm, who eventually won the silver medal, added: "I've never seen a change before."

The uproar occurred after Russia's Alexei Nemov, the defending Olympic champion on the horizontal bar, performed a routine the crowd loved but the judges didn't. He was awarded a score of 9.725 on a night when it would take 9.812 to win gold and 9.787 to get bronze.

The boos of outraged fans filled the stadium. Mr. Hamm, next in line to perform his routine, waited for the noise to die down. Two minutes. Three minutes. Five. Eight.

Finally, Mr. Nemov himself urged the crowd to shush. But it wouldn't.

"That was an interesting situation to be in," said the 44-year-old Mr. Grabowecky, a former Alberta gymnastics champion who has been judging nationally since 1986 and internationally since 1993.

"The crowd was out of control," he said. "You almost started fearing for your personal safety."

The minutes crawled past. Then Mr. Stoica, the event's chief official, huddled with the judges. "I noticed Mr. Stoica wiggle his finger at me asking me to come over to him," says Mr. Grabowecky. "He somewhat emphatically looked at me ... I went back and made the adjustment."

Mr. Grabowecky changed his mark from 9.65 to 9.75. The Malaysian judge also upped his score by a tenth of a point, lifting Mr. Nemov to a fifth-place 9.762.

"We had the head of the competition trying to find some way to control the event," said Mr. Grabowecky. "I can't comment on the rationale for that. It was his decision to act at that time, not mine ... I can't read Mr. Stoica's mind."

Mr. Grabowecky said Mr. Nemov was a crowd favourite, but didn't deserve the upgrade. "He had flashy skills but obvious errors in the performance of those skills. My score was not out of range. It wasn't wrong. It wasn't the lowest. There was no reason within the rules of gymnastics to say the score should be changed."

Mr. Grabowecky said the judges felt the pressure. "It was extremely stressful for the judges," he said. "One of the things you don't want to do in any sport, as an official, is be noticed.

"It was difficult to describe the pressure you're in. Thirteen thousand people yelling and screaming and the head of the competition asking you to do something."

Mr. Grabowecky said he felt if he didn't comply with Mr. Stoica's request he might be removed from the judging panel. "We shouldn't be judging sports of any kind based on crowd reaction," he said. "My personal feeling is it was not appropriate."

After a stretch of silence on the matter, Mr. Stoica gave his version of events yesterday to the Washington Post. The Romanian official said the revised score for Mr. Nemov had nothing to do with pleasing the crowd and was based on a re-assessment of his routine.

"Mr. Nemov had a very spectacular exercise," Mr. Stoica said, but acknowledged the gymnast's impressive series of release moves left him slightly out of position each time and open to deductions. "These two judges observed very strictly this kind of mistake and made probably a little bit too much deduction for every single release," he explained. "I asked them to try to get into the general (range) of the routine, and they did it without any problem. ... It was a little bit too severe of a deduction, that's all."

Mr. Stoica is also at the centre of a Canadian complaint --with Gymnastics Canada president Jean-Paul Caron as the chief complainant -- about strangely high marks awarded to Romanian gymnast Marian Dragulescu, who edged out Canadian Kyle Shewfelt for a bronze in the men's vault.

Despite a badly stumbled landing in his second vault, Mr. Dragulescu earned a decent 9.325 from the judges. Mr. Caron is seeking a formal explanation for the mark, which he says could only have been awarded "if judges made a mistake or were biased or were stupid."

At these Games, gymnastics has produced nearly as much scandal over judging as weightlifting has over steroids.

The most stunning case involves Mr. Hamm and the gold medal he won -- but shouldn't have -- in the men's individual all-around final, the biggest prize in the sport. The gymnastics federation has acknowledged because of a judging error in assessing the start value -- the degree of difficulty -- of South Korean gymnast Yang Tae-young's horizontal bar routine, his final score was unfairly lowered by 0.10 points.

The mistake had enormous consequences. Marked correctly, Mr. Yang would have won overall gold instead of bronze, pushing Mr. Hamm to the silver-medal spot.

Three judges involved in letting the mistake slip through -- Benjamin Bango of Spain, Oscar Buitrago Reyes of Colombia and George Beckstead of the U.S. -- were suspended by the federation. But the federation has so far refused to give Mr. Hamm's medal to Mr. Yang or approve a U.S. proposal to award a second gold to Mr. Yang.

Olympics 2004

© The Ottawa Citizen 2004








Copyright © 2004 CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest Global Communications Corp. All rights reserved.
Optimized for browser versions 4.0 and higher.
 
太长了,概括一下.
 
Canadian judge was forced to up the score for Nemov, so did the Malaysian judge.

Nemov was a crowd favourite, but didn't deserve the upgrade. "He had flashy skills but obvious errors in the performance of those skills. My score was not out of range. It wasn't wrong. It wasn't the lowest. There was no reason within the rules of gymnastics to say the score should be changed."
 
为什么别的裁判没有被forced,是不是每个裁判的分工不同?
 
最初由 March 发布
为什么别的裁判没有被forced,是不是每个裁判的分工不同?

他俩给的分低, 别的都给了9.7以上/



:blink: :blink:
 
最初由 渐渐 发布
Canadian judge was forced to up the score for Nemov, so did the Malaysian judge.

这就是得了便宜还卖乖了.
 
最初由 March 发布
为什么别的裁判没有被forced,是不是每个裁判的分工不同?
也许是别的不敢说
 
What 便宜 for Canadian judge or Malasian judge?

Their atheletes didn't even qualify for the finals.
I watched both Nemov's performance and Hamm's, I've got to say Hamm's performance was superior, although Nemov is always one of my favorite atheletes. :p

最初由 大熊猫 发布

这就是得了便宜还卖乖了.
 
最初由 渐渐 发布
What 便宜 for Canadian judge or Malasian judge?

Their atheletes didn't even qualify for the finals.
I watched both Nemov's performance and Hamm's, I've got to say Hamm's performance was superior, although Nemov is always one of my favorite atheletes. :p


JUDGE 的了好处, 才会偏心信, 又出来装可怜.

你不觉得这界, 美国的金牌, 有歧义的太多吗. 想游泳,体操什么的.


:)
 
I didn't watched too much swimming, cannot comment on that.
I did however watch gymnastics closely, and I was disappointed in some judging errors/scandals, but it's not unique to Americans, Romanians have also been a beneficiary of the judging scandals. Let's be fair here.
FIG is a little bit like figure skating now, it needs a major clean-up.
 
游泳更不要脸, 转身没碰壁, 裁判罚了后, 美国的能量大到把法国裁判罚去场, 把金牌要回来.

:(:(
 
There are execution judges and other judges, in short judges do have different functions.


最初由 人在天涯 发布

也许是别的不敢说
 
最初由 patrickpei 发布
游泳更不要脸, 转身没碰壁, 裁判罚了后, 美国的能量大到把法国裁判罚去场, 把金牌要回来.

:(:(
这个和体操,击剑是最恶心的3个.
 
后退
顶部