http://www.canada.com/ottawa/story.html?id=d86b301d-695d-4a26-acc3-f6a834c0d8cb&k=83958
Garbage deal seen as risk for Carp dump
Councillors fear landfill site will be opened to outside waste
Alexandra Zabjek and Joel Kom, The Ottawa Citizen
Published: Monday, February 27, 2006
A contract inked this month between Peel region and Waste Management of Canada -- the company that wants to expand the landfill site at Carp Road -- has again raised concerns that Ottawa will become a dumping ground for Southern Ontario garbage.
Waste Management signed a 20-year waste-disposal deal with Peel -- which includes Brampton, Mississauga and Caledon -- earlier this month that stipulates the garbage be disposed of in Ontario.
At the same time, the company has applied to double the size of the landfill at Carp Road and the Queensway, which the company says could keep it running for 25 more years.
Ottawa Councillor Janet Stavinga, who represents residents in Goulbourn, near the site of the landfill, says there are no guarantees an expanded landfill would never be opened to taking more waste from outside Ottawa.
She said she is "very concerned" the site could be used by other Ontario municipalities as a dumping ground.
"The fact that right now Waste Management, here in Ottawa, is poised to expand for another 25 years, means that we should be very concerned about the possibility that we might get waste from other areas."
Peel now sends about 30 per cent of its household garbage to Michigan, but the state's lawmakers are trying to scuttle that system. Waste Management's promise to offer "Ontario-based" solutions to the region's garbage problem is a highlight of the agreement.
The period for public comment on the proposed expansion of the Carp Road site has been extended until May 12, and Ms. Stavinga said that time should be used to get firm answers about future plans for the landfill.
"I have questions with respect to the motives. And the public and the elected officials deserve answers," Ms. Stavinga said.
Pat Saito, a Peel regional councillor who was involved in the Waste Management contract negotiations in her former position as vice-chairwoman of regional public works, advised that Ottawa city council would be wise to confirm in writing any promises from Waste Management not to import waste from Peel.
"I would want such an assurance to be so iron-clad that it was part of the certificate of approval," said Ms. Saito.
Waste Management, however, denies the Peel contract will impact Ottawa.
"This contract doesn't affect Ottawa. Nothing is coming from Toronto and nothing will come from Peel," said Michael Walters, a company spokesman.
According to its agreement in Ottawa, Waste Management must use 90 per cent of its landfill space to accommodate Ottawa's garbage, said Mr. Walters. The company is permitted to sell the remaining 10 per cent of space to other municipalities in Eastern Ontario.
If Peel needed to ship garbage to other Ontario landfills, it might consider using Waste Management's landfills near Sarnia and Napanee, said Andrew Pollock, director of waste management for the Region of Peel.
Transportation costs would make those two sites preferable over Ottawa, said Mr. Pollock.
"As far as I'm concerned, they're not planning on taking on our waste anywhere near Ottawa," said Mr. Pollock.
But the situation could change if a Michigan law passed in the fall barring Canadian garbage receives approval from the U.S. House of Representatives. In the event of a health risk, the provincial government has the power to direct garbage to any landfill in the province, the city's legal counsel, Jennifer Jackson, told a committee in October.
The Ottawa city councillor whose West Carleton ward takes in the Carp Road landfill, Eli El-Chantiry, acknowledged that the mere idea of moving Toronto-area garbage to an Ottawa landfill could cause emotional reactions, but said the scenario is unlikely.
It would not be logical for the Region of Peel to ship its garbage all the way to Ottawa, said Mr. El-Chantiry, adding Ottawa's priority should be to find alternative solutions to its own garbage issues, without expanding current landfills.
But for some fighting Waste Management's growth plans in Ottawa, the possibility of accepting garbage from other regions is still a worry.
In Carp, residents had strong feelings about garbage from outside Ottawa landing in the landfill site at Carp Road.
Resident Kathleen Krypel said she is concerned about the lack of publicity surrounding the current application to expand the landfill, especially in light of potential environmental implications. She is suspicious of the timing of the Peel contract.
"We have our own problems and we should take care of our garbage before taking it in from somewhere else," said Ms. Krypel, who lives about four kilometres from the landfill.
Business owner John Laimite, who owns Sidco Construction near the Carp Road landfill, said he believes Waste Management would try to be conscientious about its promises, but acknowledged that political moods can change over time.
Communities must deal with their own garbage issues, said Mr. Laimite, adding that shipping garbage to the United States is not a viable solution either.
© The Ottawa Citizen 2006