探亲超过183天，到底可不可以申请退税

[New Person]

我以前咨询专业人士，被告知填Caregiver amount的前提是父母有SIN，而vistor是拿不到SIN的，所以Vistor身份的父母既不能自己申请退税，也无法作为我们的eligible dependant帮我们退税。不知现在是不是还是这么规定的，如果你知道有Vistor身份成功的例子可不可以分享一下？

那是10几年前的事了，具体细节记不清了。好像要护照和来回机票。也不知要求改过没有。
Line 315 – Caregiver amount
If, at any time in 2015, you (either alone or with another person) maintained a dwelling where you and one or more of your dependants lived, you may be able to claim a maximum amount of $4,608 ($6,701 if he or she is eligible for the family caregiver amount) for each dependant.

Each dependant must have met all of the following criteria:

• He or she was18 years of age or older
• He or she had a net income in 2015 (line 236 of his or her return, or it would have been if he or she filed a return) of less than $20,343 ($22,436 if he or she was eligible for the family caregiver amount)
• He or she was dependent on you due to an impairment in physical or mental functions or, if he or she is your or your spouse's or common-law partner's parent or grandparent, was born in 1950 or earlier

 

[global]

请问你的父母是Vistor身份吗？我以前咨询专业人士，被告知填Caregiver amount的前提是父母有SIN，而vistor是拿不到SIN的，所以Vistor身份的父母既不能自己申请退税，也无法作为我们的eligible dependent 帮我们退税。不知现在是不是还是这么规定的。如果你是以父母Vistor身份成功申请到的，可不可以具体分享一下经验？

当然是visitor,要有SIN 就根本没这个deemed resident 一说了，关键是要在calendar year住满183天，根据我多年和CRA交涉的经历，不是每个人都知道这得，in fact, 很多人不知道这事会deny你的申报，我一般appeal的时候告诉他们这条，the fact is: your parents are 65 and older, deemed resident, and your parents has residence tie in Canada (as they are your dependents) 看来appeal officer 这层都aware this. hope this helps

 

[global]

不用看条文。莫名其妙给不是加拿大社会一分子的访客税务优惠，反对党一定不会放过攻击政府的机会的。自己人的Income Split 反对党尚且不放过，能默默地看着给外国人优惠？

干事想当然的人真可怕，实战出真知-：）自己试了不就知道了？worst case is you get denied and really has nothing to lose

 

[monkey88]

好像引用的这段文字与讨论的主题无关，引用的文字主要是讲加拿大人没住在加拿大，或是加拿大政府官员之类。。。
我也好像从未听说或是在哪里读到来访的家人可以报税？
我父母来住过一年，报税时我想把给他们买医保的钱报上，打电话给CRA，都说不可以。理由是父母不是经济上完全依赖于我 （非 eligible dependant)

有关系,中国大陆has tax treaty with Canada,so as visitors even live more than 183 days, not considener as deemed resident.
不可以claim caregiver amount for your parent as visitor.

 

[global]

有关系,中国大陆has tax treaty with Canada,so as visitors even live more than 183 days, not considener as deemed resident.
不可以claim caregiver amount for your parent as visitor.

从CRA网上拷下的，再好好读下-：）
Your residency status if you entered Canada

• If you left another country to settle in Canada and you established significant residential ties with Canada and became a resident of Canada in the tax year, you may be considered an immigrant.
• If you have ties in a country that Canada has a tax treaty with and you are considered to be a resident of that country, but you are also a factual resident of Canada because you established significant residential ties with Canada, you may be considered a deemed non-resident of Canada. The same rules apply to deemed non-residents as non-residents of Canada.
• If you have not established significant residential ties with Canada to be considered a factual resident, but you stayed in Canada for 183 or more days in the year, you may be considered a deemed resident of Canada.

 

[eggplant]

干事想当然的人真可怕，实战出真知-：）自己试了不就知道了？worst case is you get denied and really has nothing to lose

CRA 接受了也不代表你报对了。大多数情况下，你就是报错了，CRA 都没空理你。但万一你要是被抽中 Audit 上了，新帐旧账一块算，就不是 deny 那么简单了，利息加罚款，如果情节更严重还会被起诉。干事想当然的人真可怕。

 

[global]

CRA 接受了也不代表你报对了。大多数情况下，你就是报错了，CRA 都没空理你。但万一你要是被抽中 Audit 上了，新帐旧账一块算，就不是 deny 那么简单了，利息加罚款，如果情节更严重还会被起诉。干事想当然的人真可怕。

是呀， 问题是这样的claim是一定是会被audit的，我每年被audit, 每年通过，甚至有2年audit 后被deny, 然后appeal又拿回来了，都不知道还需要再做什么才对，要不您老给我一条CRA说不能报的理由

 

[charman]

是呀， 问题是这样的claim是一定是会被audit的，我每年被audit, 每年通过，甚至有2年audit 后被deny, 然后appeal又拿回来了，都不知道还需要再做什么才对，要不您老给我一条CRA说不能报的理由

这就是中国俗称的‘刁民’，有的是时间和政府玩儿

 

[global]

这就是中国俗称的‘刁民’，有的是时间和政府玩儿

哈哈，玩游戏按照游戏规则，特别规则还是别人定的，不知道有哪点刁了，你可以不争取本来属于你的benefit, 没人会强迫你，关键是没人会说你好，连谢谢都听不到，我只能说这种人除了傻还是傻

 

[cvictor]

是难民了，就可以报了。

 

[guanshui]

当然是visitor,要有SIN 就根本没这个deemed resident 一说了，关键是要在calendar year住满183天，根据我多年和CRA交涉的经历，不是每个人都知道这得，in fact, 很多人不知道这事会deny你的申报，我一般appeal的时候告诉他们这条，the fact is: your parents are 65 and older, deemed resident, and your parents has residence tie in Canada (as they are your dependents) 看来appeal officer 这层都aware this. hope this helps

谢谢解释得这么详细。