红十字会的龙卷风赈灾款

[c8848]

CFRA的Evan Solomon采访安省红十字会VP。龙卷风6周后，红十字会收到捐款1.3m，只发放了200k。半天没解释清楚为什么那么慢。

 

[GuardianAngel]

CFRA的Evan Solomon采访安省红十字会VP。龙卷风6周后，红十字会收到捐款1.3m，只发放了200k。半天没解释清楚为什么那么慢。

很难说钱都干嘛去了

 

[c8848]

VP说不会花很长时间。呵呵，加拿大速度。而且有保险的马上被拒了。圣诞节前也不保证。市议员Eli Chantiry很愤怒。

 

[rottenmelon]

加拿大red cross 出了名的官僚，估计这笔钱放年底准备给十字官老爷发bonus...

 

[charley2]

多年前汶川地震曾经通过红十字会捐款，后来听说捐款只有quanter percent到受灾方，......

 

[Jay Wang]

我悲粪吐槽啧！

 

[pasmo]

这个电台在舆论监督这一点上做得很好

http://www.iheartradio.ca/580-cfra/...y-the-red-cross-is-stalling-funding-1.8531230

希望后续跟进

有几段音频， 转贴不了， 值得去听听：

http://www.iheartradio.ca/580-cfra/site-search-local-7.15195509?searchField=red cross

“ON - What is the Red Cross policy for emergencies?"

 

[地坛北里]

不知道这些慈善机构的工资和运营成本是否都来自捐款？

 

[pasmo]

不知道这些慈善机构的工资和运营成本是否都来自捐款？

不然呢？

格式数据详见链接

Updated on July 27, 2018 by Joeyanne Cheung.

Financial Ratios
Fiscal year ending March 2017 2016 2015
Administrative costs as % of revenues 8.8% 15.0% 18.7%
Fundraising costs as % of donations 10.2% 18.3% 23.4%
Program cost coverage (%) 69.8% 81.8% 81.7%
Summary Financial Statements
All figures in $000s 2017 2016 2015
Donations 303,866 137,496 97,751
Government funding 267,725 139,646 122,841
Fees for service 0 0 7,015
Lotteries (net) 315 285 388
Special events 16,894 14,976 14,533
Investment income 4,001 (48) 2,182
Other income 17,917 13,462 6,803
Total revenues 610,718 305,817 251,513
Program costs - International 61,804 81,768 77,692
Program costs - Canada 357,440 146,218 147,334
Administrative costs 53,661 45,932 46,490
Fundraising costs 32,776 27,950 26,278
Other costs 0 0 678
Cash flow from operations 105,037 3,949 (46,959)
Funding reserves 292,758 186,516 183,820
Note: Ci used CRC’s T3010 filings to access government funding and international donations, which are not broken out in the audited financial statements. International donations of $8.6m in F2017, $12.4m in F2016, and $6.1m in F2015 are included in other income. Ci has adjusted deferred revenue, recognizing donations in the year they are received rather than the year donations are spent. Given CRC's disaster appeals and subsequent spending in relief and recovery this creates large deferred revenues: $89.8m in F2017, $4.6m in F2016, and ($30.8m) in F2015. Ci reports net lotteries, reducing revenues and expenses by $892k in F2017, $922k in F2016, and $1.0m in F2015.

https://www.charityintelligence.ca/charity-details/71-canadian-red-cross

 

[m234]

收钱容易，发钱还真是有点难度的．
想一下，发谁不发谁，发多少，能引起不少问题．
有保险的和没有保险的是否给同样的钱，为啥？
每家的损失会不一样，很难公平

 

[pasmo]

收钱容易，发钱还真是有点难度的．
想一下，发谁不发谁，发多少，能引起不少问题．
有保险的和没有保险的是否给同样的钱，为啥？
每家的损失会不一样，很难公平

所以需要专业机构， 专业人士呢。

可能没有比红会更值得信任的机构， 红会也不是第一次做类似的事情了， 应该遵循既定的政策行动才是。

完全的公平是不可能的， 如果遵循既定政策， 起码事后检阅的是政策而不是当时的官僚， 偷懒， 拖延和不作为

真希望这次能够触发红会的内部改革

 

[一亩三分地]

大家需要了解一下NGO的运作方法
所谓无盈利组织的意思是，他们不额外赚钱，但是operation的cost还是需要的，收到的钱就用在这方面。
怎么运营，开多少工资是一回事，剩下的怎么分配是另外一回事。

 

[Anakin]

准备集体去红会网站留言：捐你妹？

 

[c8848]

有cost没问题。问题是收了1.3m，救灾才发了200k。

 

[GuardianAngel]

不知道这些慈善机构的工资和运营成本是否都来自捐款？

当然。要不能从哪儿来？