中英文媒体对此事评论纷纷,CFC上也有许多偏激的论点, 大使今天又被炒了鱿鱼。事到如今让大家回头看看自由党大佬,曾任加拿大工业部长,外交部长,财长,代总理的John Manley 12月15号对孟一案的看法。也许对大家对此事的理解有帮助。
John Manley是咱窝村土生土长的政治家, 律师。没上过大藤, Carleton university 的 BA ,University of Ottawa 的LLA(等于现在的JD)。
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Manley
John Paul Manley PC OC (born January 5, 1950) is a
Canadian lawyer,
businessman, and
politician. He served as
Liberal Member of Parliament for
Ottawa South from
1988 to
2004, and was
deputy prime minister between 2002 and 2003. From January 2010 until October 2018 he was
President and
CEO of the
Business Council of Canada.
下面是John Manley 12月15号在CBC Radio对孟一案的看法。
对土豆政府为美国抓孟,
John Paul Manley说:“we find ourselves in a situation where lots of warning bells should have gone off, this was not an extradition of somebody who was a drug trafficker, you know a human smuggler, or any of the typical thing is that we find people getting extradited for. This is a senior executive of a global company. Yes, they accuse Huawei of doing things that they ought not to have done. But before you arrest somebody in that category, you make awfully with sure that this is really what it's claimed to be. And I think the president (Trump) has made it pretty clear that's not what it was at all".
John Manley 还谈到:“ I think it was a good opportunity for a little bit of creative incompetence on the part of Canadian authorities. And
somehow just miss her. This has happened from time to time that we sometimes don't always do exactly everything we needed to do. And the world wouldn't have really been any wiser about it”.
仅仅是麦大使说了不该说的话,把此案政治化了吗?土豆和加外长就没有?两人在抓孟后都曾公开表示他们事先知道。看看
John Paul Manley开始怎么说的:“ The trouble with the prime minister having been informed — and I don't think he should have been — is that to the Chinese that means this was political. The prime minister was informed. And you know I think extradition matters, prime ministers shouldn't even necessarily know who's on such lists that there are extradition requests about.
We don't run our law that way.
在此事上,中国应该尊重加拿大法律?
John Manley说:“ And rule of law is one of the fundamental principles of the Canadian system. But
we could also be talking about abuse of process. And to abuse legal processes is not to respect the rule of law it’s to abuse the rule of law.
John Manley在这里指美国滥用法律, 而且加的的处理过程也有问题。
加拿大应该如何解决此事?
John Paul Manley说:“My hope is that there are people burning the midnight oil at the Justice Department to see if that advice (drop this extradition process) can be given to the attorney general. And "I actually do think it's an abuse of process, and it should be brought to an end as quickly as possible. But the communication of that would be very tricky".
当然,John Manley对中国抓2位加拿大人也很愤怒,认为无助于问题的解决而把问题复杂化了。
麦大使说的都是实话,对加拿大好的话。我相信在土豆召集6国大使开会他发表了同样的见解。我认为土豆政府会教条式的走下去。就如他的内阁必须50%的女性,Omar Khadr, 沙特一事的做法。人没有基本的智慧,只知道几个教条的人领导一个国家好戏会一个接一个来的。
声明: 本人长期自由党选民,以前大选让自由党在房前插牌,上次大选我拒绝了并明确说只要土豆当头我不去投票。
https://www.cbc.ca/radio/asithappen...thinks-canada-botched-huawei-affair-1.4946539