Cable vs. ADSL 差不多吗?

  • 主题发起人 主题发起人 guest
  • 开始时间 开始时间

guest

Moderator
管理成员
注册
2002-10-07
消息
402,179
荣誉分数
76
声望点数
0
<HTML>觉得我的Sympatico ADSL连接最近有些不稳,常有十几秒钟毫无连接的现象。我正在考虑换成Rogers的Cable。价钱好象差不多,不知速度上有差别吗?会有什么样的问题?</HTML>
 
<HTML>两种接入在原理上不同, 一种是大锅饭, 吃的人多了, 每个人碗里的自然就少了(Rogers), 另外一种是开小灶, 不管人多人少, 碗有多大就吃多少(xDSL).</HTML>
 
<HTML>DSL's speed is constantly, it doesn't related to rush hour or not. But Rogers' cable do related to how many user in your neighbour, so the speed of Rogers' cable can drop down significantly during the rush hours. BTW, DSL's speed is related to distancce from your location to the DSL's center. I have experienced both of them, I prefer DSL much more than Rogers' cable, not only the speed and also the service.

For difficult to estiblish the connection, do you use W2K and also using obtain the IP address automaticly? if so, you can specify the IP address for your network adpater, just like 192.168.0.1, then the problem will be gone.

The easy way is just call Bell Sympatico technical support, tell them your problem, they will help you to slove it. That's my experience.</HTML>
 
<HTML>From my experience,
here ADSL is slower.

Sawol</HTML>
 
<HTML>OS: windows95
Service: Rogers Cable
Test site: http://www.speedtest.net
Time: 9:00pm Jan 6, 2002
Speed(Mbps): 1.078 1.130 1.111 1.111 1.113 1.113 1.005 1.087 1.103</HTML>
 
<HTML>按理说Cable应该比ASDL要快,但Rogers共享接入肯定与同时上网人树有关系,也与上网的人的活动状态有关系(比如有人采用多线程下载软件或影视节目)。我现在也在考虑选那种方式接入呢。</HTML>

[%sig%]
 
<HTML>OS: windows98
Service: Sympatico ADSL
Test site: http://www.speedtest.net
Test type: 200 kilobytes, download
Time: 9:40pm Jan 6, 2002
Speed(Mbps): 0.187, 0.132, 0.134, 0.183, 0.146, 0.159, 0.155

really slow when compared with the above calble test!!!
anybody can do more test?</HTML>
 
<HTML>Test: 25 kb, upload
Speed(Mbps): 0.091, 0.093, 0.093, 0.094

Surprised me, not very different (only half) from download speed! Something must be wrong with my ADSL. Download speed for ADSL should be around 0.4 Mbps, true?</HTML>
 
<HTML>打电话到Sympatico,被告知在下面的site测速:
http://fastweb.sympatico.ca/test/ontario/en.html
结果是1MB的download平均速度为264 kilobits/sec,还在他们guarantee的250 kbps之上。我还以为保证的网速是350 kbps呢!Cable如何?</HTML>
 
<HTML>Test starting...
Average throughput: 2048 kilobits/sec
Total Time: 4096 milliseconds
Done.

To my surprise, my cable speed is much faster than your ADSL. I used ADSL before, they provided me 1.3M. But I feel it is slower than cable.</HTML>
 
<HTML>Using the above sympatico site,
Time: 11:00pm Jan 6, 2002
Download size: 1MB
Speed(Mbps): 1.052 1.004 1.045 1.075

Usually my upload speed is around 360kbps.</HTML>
 
<HTML>那我的是否太惨了点?


OS: windows2000 Pro
Service: VIF dial-up 56K Modem
Test site: http://www.speedtest.net
Test type: 50 kilobytes, download
Speed: 0.023Mbps</HTML>

[%sig%]
 
<HTML>根据Sympatico电话里的建议,我重装了网卡的driver。之后再测试的5次结果为
1MB Download: 326,514,594,309,477 kbps
看来还是Cable快啊!</HTML>
 
<HTML>Actually, I always can experience 1.1Mbps(average),1.2Mbps(peak) speed with ADSL.It is downloading using flashget or downloading from big site like microsoft,intel...

But I don't think it is faster than Cable.

My friend's Cable, speed up to 300kB/s(around 3Mbps).

If you still can not get higher speed than 300kbps, you
can go download some crack or manualy change registry.
That might be helpful , but the 1.2Mbps is the max speed.

Sympatico has limit on the server side-1.2Mbps.

Sawol</HTML>
 
<HTML>早上再测试三次的结果:
1MB Download: 843, 834, 829 kbps</HTML>
 
后退
顶部