Rodenstock vs. B+W

[Xterra]

Which one makes better UV filters? Is Rodenstock filter considered as execellent ones?

thanks!

 

[startrack]

Rodenstock and Schneider(B+W) are both top line of German Glass, they are both good, I mean excellent.
In Large format system. Rodenstock lens has more details and Schneider is sharper. If i were you, I will stay with B+W.

 

[杨戬]

henrys B+W缺货，如果急着入手，可以选择Hoya的super UV(o)

 

[Xterra]

I was going to buy from Henry's initially. However, the plan has changed due to the price factor. Although Simon's offer is slightly higher than Henry's before taxes, the grand totals are reversed. Simon's offer comes about $190 shorter than Henry's. The only difference here is Simon's does not have B+W, they have Rodenstock filters instead. If I don't buy filters from simons, I will have to pay the full price for those B+W filter at Henry's afterwards, the regular prices of B+W filters at henry's are about doubled from what I have been offered within the package. I just hestitate... I am sure who I should make a deal with.

To make my decision easier, I use the filters to decide who I will go with:
1> if Rodenstock UV filters are as exceptional, crisp and clear as Schneider, I will go with Simon's, since I have nothing to lose, but some savings.
2> if Rodenstock is bad. I mean bad enough to defeat my L class lenses. I will definately go with Henry's, after all $190 on savings will make my big spending on lenses a real stupid decision.

What do you guys think? Please give me a hand on this one!

I will much appreciate!

 

[sean]

I go with http://stores.ebay.com/Schneider-Store_W0QQcolZ4QQdirZ1QQftidZ2QQtZkm

The owner is Chinese guy Raymond Yip in Guangzhou. I bought my B+W from him, really nice. He even can offer you the price lower than the list.

最初由 Xterra 发布
I was going to buy from Henry's initially. However, the plan has changed due to the price factor. Although Simon's offer is slightly higher than Henry's before taxes, the grand totals are reversed. Simon's offer comes about $190 shorter than Henry's. The only difference here is Simon's does not have B+W, they have Rodenstock filters instead. If I don't buy filters from simons, I will have to pay the full price for those B+W filter at Henry's afterwards, the regular prices of B+W filters at henry's are about doubled from what I have been offered within the package. I just hestitate... I am sure who I should make a deal with.

To make my decision easier, I use the filters to decide who I will go with:
1> if Rodenstock UV filters are as exceptional, crisp and clear as Schneider, I will go with Simon's, since I have nothing to lose, but some savings.
2> if Rodenstock is bad. I mean bad enough to defeat my L class lenses. I will definately go with Henry's, after all $190 on savings will make my big spending on lenses a real stupid decision.

What do you guys think? Please give me a hand on this one!

I will much appreciate!

 

[fad]

最初由 sean 发布
I go with http://stores.ebay.com/Schneider-Store_W0QQcolZ4QQdirZ1QQftidZ2QQtZkm

The owner is Chinese guy Raymond Yip in Guangzhou. I bought my B+W from him, really nice. He even can offer you the price lower than the list.

I can vouch for Raymond. Bought a few UV/CPL from him and his price can't be beaten. Thanks sean for the tip.