原来超载并不犯法,今天刚知道 [闲聊]

cfc_usr

新手上路
注册
2003-02-27
消息
202
荣誉分数
0
声望点数
0
一直以为小车不能坐多于seatbelt数的人,看来不对。
周六一位太太开着大吉普,有4,5个孩子在车上,不幸在进417时翻车,导致一个坐truck附近没有系保险带的男孩死亡。
警察叔叔这么解释:
the law requires only that all passengers in a seated position wear a seatbelt and no one shares a belt, so it is not against the law to carry more passengers than there are seatbelts as long as all seatbelts in the vehicle are use.

周末在唐人街看到一位开着烤肉拉,里面坐着6个人。
前面是两位父亲,后面是两位母亲,一个大孩子,另一个小孩子抱在年轻的妈妈的怀里。
真为他们一大家子捏把汗。
BTW,他们这么坐倒真的违法了。
 
最初由 cfc_usr 发布
一直以为小车不能坐多于seatbelt数的人,看来不对。
周六一位太太开着大吉普,有4,5个孩子在车上,不幸在进417时翻车,导致一个坐truck附近没有系保险带的男孩死亡。
警察叔叔这么解释:
the law requires only that all passengers in a seated position wear a seatbelt and no one shares a belt, so it is not against the law to carry more passengers than there are seatbelts as long as all seatbelts in the vehicle are use.

周末在唐人街看到一位开着烤肉拉,里面坐着6个人。
前面是两位父亲,后面是两位母亲,一个大孩子,另一个小孩子抱在年轻的妈妈的怀里。
真为他们一大家子捏把汗。
BTW,他们这么坐倒真的违法了。
you are not allowed to do so if you are holding a G2 lisense...
 
就发现部分同胞到加以后变的异常的遵法守法依法,动不动就法规,违法,有些时候老外都不当回事,咱得先好好研究研究,一大奇观。
 
最初由 大呼悠 发布
就发现部分同胞到加以后变的异常的遵法守法依法,动不动就法规,违法,有些时候老外都不当回事,咱得先好好研究研究,一大奇观。

不是部分, 是大部分, 这叫入乡随俗.

只有脑袋灌水的才会我行我素, 和法律脚板, 自我感觉还特牛B.


前面是两位父亲,后面是两位母亲,一个大孩子,另一个小孩子抱在年轻的妈妈的怀里。

好象这和G2没什么关系吧, 应该是
(1)12岁以下
(2)80磅以下
(3)140CM以下
不满足上述任何一条的人, 必须有CAR SEAT

如果抱着大孩子是不是不违法了?
 
真不知道楼主如何从“the law requires only that all passengers in a seated position wear a seatbelt and no one shares a belt” 推出“小车可以坐多于seatbelt数的人”的结论的。
 
最初由 Beleriand 发布


不是部分, 是大部分, 这叫入乡随俗.

只有脑袋灌水的才会我行我素, 和法律脚板, 自我感觉还特牛B.



好象这和G2没什么关系吧, 应该是
(1)12岁以下
(2)80磅以下
(3)140CM以下
不满足上述任何一条的人, 必须有CAR SEAT

如果抱着大孩子是不是不违法了?
G2 license 规则:车上的乘客数和不能超过安全带数,亦即不能超载(那位有G2 license的可以看看背面的说明)。注意,我说得是G2超载不合法。G license没有类似规定。
你见过在bus,taxi上装car seat的吗?新生儿出院如果是坐taxi或者bus,护士不检查car seat.
 
最初由 Beleriand 发布


不是部分, 是大部分, 这叫入乡随俗.

有的人在国内钻法律空子,过来以后戴上帽子,也开始"随俗"了。那只能叫虚伪。做人要坦荡,西方不欣赏教条主义。看来中国人就是贱,在国内嫌不自由,到了自由西方还总喜欢找点法律条文来折腾自己。
 
我是不理解LZ转述的警察的解释, 即法律有没有规定车上可以坐超过额定座位的乘客.

mooncake把它和G2关联起来和这个问题无关; 如果拿BUS,TAXI来辩解就更是在故意抬杠了, 因为BUS和TAXI是和一般的FAMILY CAR不同的, 它们的专用道,你的车是不能跑的, 如同警车可以闯红灯不能证明创红灯合法一样.


大呼悠 发言似乎有发泄的嫌疑了, 如果有本事不遵守规则,又能逃避惩罚那是牛人, 但需要你熟练掌握规则. 这样你将是大家的偶像了; 如果稀里糊涂, 啥也不懂, 老挨闷棍, 就成众人取笑的对象了.
 
http://www.cbc.ca/ottawa/story/ot-seatbelt20051115.html

Boy's death highlights 'flaw' in seatbelt law

The death of a 13-year-old Ottawa boy in an accident on the Queensway has revealed what some critics believe is a serious flaw in Ontario's seatbelt law.

Cameron Smith, of Kanata, was killed when he was ejected from an SUV that rolled over several times after the driver lost control of the vehicle on Saturday night.

The SUV was carrying a 38-year-old driver and seven passengers. Four of them were teenagers and three were children. But it had just five seatbelts. Smith was one of two passengers who had no access to a seatbelt.

In Ontario, it's not against the law to carry more passengers than there are seatbelts in a vehicle, as long as all the seatbelts are being used, and as long as the driver is not inhibited by any of the passengers.

The victim's father, Alisdair Smith, says his son was smart enough to know he should be wearing a seatbelt. But, he says, Cameron was also the type to make sacrifices for others.

"If there weren't enough [seatbelts], I can easily see him as being the person who would say, 'Okay, you have it, I'll sit in the back.' You know, recognizing that that wasn't as safe, wasn't as appropriate. That was the sort of person that he was," Smith says.

But organizations such as the Canadian Automobile Association and the Canada Safety Council say the boy shouldn't have had to make that choice.

They want Ontario to follow Quebec's lead, and restrict the number of people in a vehicle to the number of seatbelts available.

Ontario's minister of Transportation, Harinder Takhar, says seatbelt laws are there to save lives.

"It's unfortunate about what happened in Ottawa. We are going to look at this legislation."

The Ontario Provincial Police say a report on exactly what happened in the accident could be released by the end of the week.

------------------------------
中国有句古话:小心驶得万年船。

那孩子可是Straight-A student,可惜了。
 
最初由 Beleriand 发布
我是不理解LZ转述的警察的解释, 即法律有没有规定车上可以坐超过额定座位的乘客.
mooncake把它和G2关联起来和这个问题无关 .
你还不明白?ontario法律不禁止G牌司机超载,如果当时司机拿的是G2 license,他就违法了。
 
最初由 mooncake 发布

你还不明白?ontario法律不禁止G牌司机超载,如果当时司机拿的是G2 license,他就违法了。

你是刚明白吧?

我问的是法律是否允许一辆车里面座多于...的人, 注意,这是车和人的关系, 你所谓的G2是Restriction.
 
最初由 Beleriand 发布


你是刚明白吧?

我问的是法律是否允许一辆车里面座多于...的人, 注意,这是车和人的关系, 你所谓的G2是Restriction.
No. 这是车,人和执照的关系,看来你还是不明白。
 
最初由 Beleriand 发布
看完您这贴, 我就全明白了.
请问,关于超载到底有什么规定?还真不明白其中细节。
 
后退
顶部