在报税时，如何填写中加协议

[popyard007]

I already mentioned the money for a student is ordinary from two parts. Research assistant (or teaching assistant) is a job and you have EI as mentioned in your T4 form. The other part is scholarship, which no EI was reduced (T4A or T4E?). The scholarship part is qualified for tax reduction.
But everyone need file a tax return, otherwise how can you get your money back as your tax is already in CRA?

Nobody is surprised.
Where is this 中加税收协议 saying postdocs don't pay tax in Canada--Show me.

I came to Canada as a student. With the little money I made as a research assistant, I still had to fill in my tax form. Mind you, I did not get OHIP or any other benifits.

 

[Chewy]

我觉得其实应该仔细阅读文件

http://www.fin.gc.ca/treaties-conventions/china_-eng.asp
Students

Payments which a student, apprentice or business trainee who is, or was immediately before visiting a Contracting State, a resident of the other Contracting State and who is present in the first-mentioned Contracting State solely for the purpose of his education or training receives for the purpose of his maintenance, education or training shall not be taxed in that Contracting State.

The key words here are student, apprentice or business trainee.
Postdocs come to Canada on work permit. They are not under any of these categories.

 

[ccc]

我仔细阅读了一下那个文件，其实一开头就解释得很清楚了。
你在哪国居住，你就按照哪国的规定缴税。
这是为了避免出现Double Taxation的问题，这个其实是为了你好。
...

开头就说了，哪里挣的钱，就在哪里报税，也就是那个文件里的＂一方＂、＂另一方＂；避免双重税务。

问题是人家是想彻底避开。

 

[苦逼热狗]

什么架设都是站不稳脚的，不管是普通本科学生还是博士后，都要交税的。你自己不file tax return的话，是自己的问题。中加税收协议的税收是按照当前居住国来征收的，跟你是哪国公民没有关系的。我当本科生的时候也要交税的，不过有tuition credit，现在拿着工签，也交着税，我自始至终都不用交中国那头的税，这就是那个合约的本质，你不需要交纳国内的个人所得税。

 

[Chewy]

I already mentioned the money for a student is ordinary from two parts. Research assistant (or teaching assistant) is a job and you have EI as mentioned in your T4 form. The other part is scholarship, which no EI was reduced (T4A or T4E?). The scholarship part is qualified for tax reduction.
But everyone need file a tax return, otherwise how can you get your money back as your tax is already in CRA?


Don't beat around the bush.
Where is this 中加税收协议 saying postdocs who get paid from a Canadian institute, receiving Canadian benefit and residing in Canada don't pay Canada tax?
Show me.

 

[苦逼热狗]

合法避税是可以的，逃税是违法的。实在无法解开这个心节就打电话给CRA，告诉对方有这个tax treaty，人家自然有权威解释。

 

[popyard007]

Whether LZ will apply for this tax reduction or not is her choice.
You could warn her that you think she might be not qualified for this 中加税收协议. But it is so wrong to say any bad words about her decision. Because she deserved the right to apply for any tax reduction legally.
What is more, she is a Chinese, other Chinese should provide more help instead of pissing her off. You don't want to be pissed off by others, do you?

The key words here are student, apprentice or business trainee.
Postdocs come to Canada on work permit. They are not under any of these categories.

 

[popyard007]

It is none of your business, right?

So, it sounds you are the SO of LZ. Right?

 

[popyard007]

Now this is a good suggestion.

合法避税是可以的，逃税是违法的。实在无法解开这个心节就打电话给CRA，告诉对方有这个tax treaty，人家自然有权威解释。

 

[Chewy]

什么架设都是站不稳脚的，不管是普通本科学生该是博士后，都要交税的。你自己不file tax return的话，是自己的问题。中加税收协议的税收是按照当前居住国来征收的，跟你是哪国公民没有关系的。我当本科生的时候也要交税的，不过有tuition credit，现在拿着工签，也交着税，我自始至终都不用交中国那头的税，这就是那个合约的本质，你不需要交纳国内的个人所得税。

LZ哪头都不想交。想用这个“中加税收协议”把加方税逃掉，中国方嘛，“说是回国交,其实不要交,也没人找你要啊”。

她要是没享受到啥福利咱也就不说啥了，没我啥事嘛。可她生孩子是OHIP，孩子医疗是OHIP，家访护士也是OHIP, 想领牛奶金估计未果. 这所有的免费服务里，都有你我一分都没少交的税-- So this is my business and every single tax payer's business.

 

[popyard007]

You have no idea about this 中加税收协议. You can't provide the information LZ needed. So why not shut your mouth.

I already mentioned the money for a student is ordinary from two parts. Research assistant (or teaching assistant) is a job and you have EI as mentioned in your T4 form. The other part is scholarship, which no EI was reduced (T4A or T4E?). The scholarship part is qualified for tax reduction.
But everyone need file a tax return, otherwise how can you get your money back as your tax is already in CRA?


Don't beat around the bush.
Where is this 中加税收协议 saying postdocs who get paid from a Canadian institute, receiving Canadian benefit and residing in Canada don't pay Canada tax?
Show me.

 

[苦逼热狗]

Now, I LOL'd.

 

[ccc]

It is none of your business, right?

No.

But as it is posted here, people can discuss the issue as they understand it.

And ...

合法避税是可以的，逃税是违法的。...。

 

[Chewy]

It is none of your business, right?

Not, it is not right.
If you are the LZ hubby who is trying so hard not to pay Canadian tax, it actually becomes every tax payer's business. If you are not the hubby, well, this is a public websit where people can ask questions.
That's how we pay the game in Canada. Better get used to it.

Where you are standing on the issue depends on where you sit.

 

[ccc]

LZ哪头都不想交。想用这个“中加税收协议”把加方税逃掉，中国方嘛，“说是回国交,其实不要交,也没人找你要啊”。

她要是没享受到啥福利咱也就不说啥了，没我啥事嘛。可她生孩子是OHIP，孩子医疗是OHIP，家访护士也是OHIP, 想领牛奶金估计未果. 这所有的免费服务里，都有你我一分都没少交的税-- So this is my business and every single tax payer's business.