美籍华人因泄露国家机密罪 在北京判刑8年罚款20万

[他山之石]

Now let's talk about the fairness of Xue's sentence. Obviously his wife and his adviser do not think it is fair:

"I can't describe how I feel. It's definitely unacceptable," Xue's wife, Nan Kang, said by telephone, sobbing, from their home in a Houston, Texas, suburb where she lives with their two children.

David Rowley, Xue's thesis adviser at University of Chicago and a geologist, said that the location and seismic and other data of oil wells is commonly available and could not compromise Chinese security since the government controls access.
"What frightens me most about this is that Xue Feng is, in my experience, a straight-up individual who worked hard, who didn't push limits, or try to pull a fast one by, but was simply honest and entirely well meaning," Rowley said in an e-mail. "That's IHS's business -- acquiring and redistributing data (bases) so he was simply doing his job."

 

[Country on wheel]

和TG讲fair， too simple， too naive。这比秦会"莫需有"的罪名透明多了。知足吧。聪明人，老老实在北美混日子。中国的财不是那么好发的。(听着象是酸葡萄心理 )

 

[handy man]

废话! 美国籍的,美国政府不撑腰,谁撑?

抓个英国毒贩,还有英国政府撑腰呢.

不说“治外法权”时期，就是一二十年前，豪强们一放狠话，中国政府忙不迭把这些烫手山芋“驱逐出境”了事。现在倒要看看中国政府是不是装硬气，关几天就“驱逐出境”。

 

[ccc]

如果是IHS派去中国公差，这家公司应该对他负有全责。

 

[Country on wheel]

如果是IHS派去中国公差，这家公司应该对他负有全责。

20万的罚款公司肯定替他交了。但是8年煎寓谁也替不了。44岁，出来都过半百了。

 

[南极找南难]

20万的罚款公司肯定替他交了。但是8年煎寓谁也替不了。44岁，出来都过半百了。

45岁生日就能在美国的豪宅里过. 连热比亚都让出国, 他还真的能服刑?!

 

[ccc]

20万的罚款公司肯定替他交了。但是8年煎寓谁也替不了。44岁，出来都过半百了。

估计有这２０万垫底，他很快就会被＂驱逐出境＂。

 

[handy man]

20万的罚款公司肯定替他交了。但是8年煎寓谁也替不了。44岁，出来都过半百了。

按中国法律，刑期从判决执行之日起计算；判决执行前先行羁押的，羁押1日折抵刑期2日。 他已被羁押2年8个月。最多再服刑2年多就刑满释放。

 

[闲得慌]

Now let's talk about the fairness of Xue's sentence. Obviously his wife and his adviser do not think it is fair:

"I can't describe how I feel. It's definitely unacceptable," Xue's wife, Nan Kang, said by telephone, sobbing, from their home in a Houston, Texas, suburb where she lives with their two children.

David Rowley, Xue's thesis adviser at University of Chicago and a geologist, said that the location and seismic and other data of oil wells is commonly available and could not compromise Chinese security since the government controls access.
"What frightens me most about this is that Xue Feng is, in my experience, a straight-up individual who worked hard, who didn't push limits, or try to pull a fast one by, but was simply honest and entirely well meaning," Rowley said in an e-mail. "That's IHS's business -- acquiring and redistributing data (bases) so he was simply doing his job."

看看这个教授写的啥东西：

教授的第一点是“the location and seismic and other data of oil wells is commonly available ".
这些关于中国油井的资料是不是敏感信息，不是由西方国家说了算，也不是由小薛同学说了算，更不是由David Rowley教授说了算的。唯一的权威机构是中国政府。再说了，如果是公开的资料，谁都能弄到，小薛同学还能收集这些信息卖钱吗？这个教授逻辑不行。

教授的第二点是“Xue Feng is, in my experience, a straight-up individual who worked hard, who didn't push limits, or try to pull a fast one by, but was simply honest and entirely well meaning."
教授在这里暴露了他识人不行。小薛同学已经对偷偷收集母国敏感资料准备卖给美国的事实供认不讳，他还要坚持说小薛同学是正直，诚实的人。这个教授跟事实对着干，不自量力。

总之，此教授是垃圾！

 

[shoppingcart]

海华贼汉奸不抓JJ比冠希还坚挺，一抓都心脏有病，真是啥X性！

海华是ＦＢＩ，CSIS 和国安局都喜欢抓捕的动物

 

[Coast]

在美国收集一些看起来很常见的东西，如果卖给中国，就可能惹麻烦，没有那么多为什么！说你有罪你就有罪，别恬着脸讲什么道理！

同样，在中国相似的情况也可能有类似的后果。同样的，这时候讲道理是很天真的事！

 

[ccc]

在美国收集一些看起来很常见的东西，如果卖给中国，就可能惹麻烦，没有那么多为什么！说你有罪你就有罪，别恬着脸讲什么道理！

同样，在中国相似的情况也可能有类似的后果。同样的，这时候讲道理是很天真的事！

在这个问题上，全世界所有的国家都是一样的，美国、西欧的法规往往更复杂。

 

[Country on wheel]

这些人都是中-美斗法用的纸牌。要想放薛蜂，懊八吗就得让步给点甜头。不信看着。
只是谁当牌谁倒霉。

 

[charley2]

他一个学地质的，串回中国收集地球物理的数据库，又是涉及油气机密的，太敏感了。

都是钱和利益所致。

 

[ccc]

那家IHS公司是干什么的？http://www.ihs.com/

About IHS Inc.
IHS (NYSE: IHS) is a leading global source of critical information and insight dedicated to providing the most complete and trusted information and expertise. IHS product and service solutions span four areas of information that encompass the most important concerns facing global business today: Energy, Product Lifecycle, Security, and Environment, all supported by Macroeconomics. By focusing on our customers first, IHS enables innovative and successful decision-making for customers ranging from governments and multinational companies to smaller companies and technical professionals in more than 180 countries. IHS celebrated its 50th anniversary in 2009 and employs approximately 4,000 people in 20 countries.