Symbolic violence

chicago666

资深人士
注册
2015-09-07
消息
7,460
荣誉分数
1,350
声望点数
223
汉语在符号上天然就充满专制,还是被污染了以后,形成了一种symbolic violence?

我比较倾向后者,但是前者也有to some extent.

总而言之,polluted from the root, that's my opinion.

Symbolic violence语见Pierre Bourdieu
 
最后编辑:
文化的再生产,阶级的再生产,能看见的是一个不断强化的趋势。
 
是指文字狱?

不知其他使用汉语的国家有什么正反例?
 
The concept of symbolic power, also known as symbolic domination (domination symbolique in French language) or symbolic violence, was first introduced by French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu to account for the tacit, almost unconscious modes of cultural/social domination occurring within the everyday social habits maintained over conscious subjects. Symbolic power accounts for discipline used against another to confirm that individual's placement in a social hierarchy, at times in individual relations but most basically through system institutions, in particular education.

Also referred to as soft power, symbolic power includes actions that have discriminatory or injurious meaning or implications, such as gender dominance and racism. Symbolic power maintains its effect through the mis-recognition of power relations situated in the social matrix of a given field. While symbolic power requires a dominator, it also requires the dominated to accept their position in the exchange of social value that occurs between them.


Contents
1History
2See also
3References
4External links
History[edit]
The concept of symbolic power may be seen as grounded in Friedrich Engels' concept of false consciousness. To Engels, under capitalism, objects and social relationships themselves are embedded with societal value that is dependent upon the actors who engage in interactions themselves.[1] Without the illusion of natural law governing such transactions of social and physical worth, the proletariat would be unwilling to consciously support social relations that counteract their own interests. Dominant actors in a society must consciously accept that such an ideological order exists for unequal social relationships to take place. Louis Althusser further developed it in his writing on what he called Ideological State Apparatuses, arguing that the latter's power is partly based on symbolic repression.[2]

The concept of symbolic power was first introduced by Pierre Bourdieu in La Distinction. Bourdieu suggested that cultural roles are more dominant than economic forces in determining how hierarchies of power are situated and reproduced across societies. Status and economic capital are both necessary to maintain dominance in a system, rather than just ownership over the means of production alone. The idea that one could possess symbolic capital in addition and set apart from financial capital played a critical role in Bourdieu's analysis of hierarchies of power.

For example, in the process of reciprocal gift exchange in the Kabyle society of Algeria, where there is asymmetry in wealth between the two parties the better endowed giver "can impose a strict relation of hierarchy and debt upon the receiver."[3] Symbolic power, therefore, is fundamentally the imposition of categories of thought and perception upon dominated social agents who, once they begin observing and evaluating the world in terms of those categories—and without necessarily being aware of the change in their perspective—then perceive the existing social order as just. This, in turn, perpetuates a social structure favored by and serving the interests of those agents who are already dominant.[4] Symbolic power, if real, is in some senses much more powerful than physical violence in that it is embedded in the very modes of action and structures of cognition of individuals, and imposes the specter of legitimacy of the social order.
 
象征性力量从根本上讲是将思想和感知类别强加给占主导地位的社会代理人,一旦他们开始根据这些类别观察和评估世界,并且不一定意识到他们观点的变化,就会认为现有的社会秩序是公正的。这反过来又延续了那些已经占主导地位的代理人所青睐和服务的社会结构。4]象征性力量,如果是真实的,在某些意义上比身体暴力强大得多,因为它植根于个人的行动模式和认知结构中,并强加了社会秩序的合法性幽灵。
 
常春藤好歹也有真材实料,211纯粹是中国人自己玩自己。
 
我感觉常春藤的历史很悠久了,有些学校已经明显落伍,已经被MIT,斯坦福等新秀全面赶超。

中国的名校不至于全不如人吧?
 
后退
顶部