最初由 roaring mouse 发布
yokel. by your viewpoints, no social progress is possible. there has to be a beginning. if u think china is tightly controlled and you cannot and dare not fight back, then stop whining and patiently suffer your fate. Government's faults are from its people. If people do not stand up to rectify the faults, the faults will continue. See the courageous people of Nepal and see how they fight to end un-democracy. By your viewpoints, even the Americans could not win the war against the British, whose army was far more powerful than the American farmer army. The communists would never have won over the KMT as the KMT army was far superior to the Mao's peasant army. Because China has people like you, it could be invaded by the manchurians and the japanese because you dared not to fight a more powerful enemy.
I think you have never heard of civil disobedience. When you accept defeat, you are defeated.
glad you find it gratifying in the washroom. hope your soul is washed clean there too.
yokel, the king of Nepal gave up his power. If you do not stand up against evil, you become evil. again government's faults are from it people. live and learn.
"by your viewpoints, no social progress is possible."
Looks like you either don't understand my point at all, or trying to twist my point.
This is what I said.
"doing the right thing at the right time". If you don't understand what it means, just ask people here for help, or find someone to read my line and explain it to you. If you want to blame Chinese people for the existence of the regime, or if you want to compare China with the countries of your favorite category, be my guest. You don't have to try so hard to twist the meaning of other people's words, or to try so desperately to put your words into other people's mouth. It will only make you look desperate.
"See the courageous people of Nepal and see how they fight to end un-democracy"
Now you are ignorant again comparing Nepal to China. Lets me just give you one of the differences between China and Nepal because I am tired of listing differences to you and you don't seem to understand anyway. Nepal is a country that can not even take care of Mao guerrillas. Any guerrillas in China? Did Nepal government use machine guns and tanks on its citizens/protesters?
"By your viewpoints, even the Americans could not win the war against the British, whose army was far more powerful than the American farmer army"
You need to re-read my point again, or find someone read it and explain it to you. The quoted below between the dotted lines is what I said last time.
-----------------------------------------------
The American British War around 1777 was totally different from the situation in China today. Here are some of the differences:
- There were very few British army in the colonies unlike the army, armed police, police, secrete police etc all over the places in China.
- No media control from British government
- No systematic governmental control on society from the top to the smallest unit in villages
- No nation-wide British police control
- No firearm control
- No control on forming armies and militia, and parties
- Big culture difference
The list can go on and on. Does any of the factors apply to China? If China had only one difference such as having a freedom of press, then you will see difference.
-----------------------------------------------
Looks like I need to explain what's so obvious to you again. The paragraph means that what can be done in US does not necessarily mean the same can be done in China at any point of time.
By the way who told you the British army was
"far more powerful than the American farmer army"? The British army did not even have the power to fight the Independence that was declared a year before the American-British war.
"glad you find it gratifying in the washroom. hope your soul is washed clean there too."
I guess that's the best you can do...LOL
Yes, I may feel
"gratifying" and
"uplifting" in that situation, and I think many people may feel similar way. But the difference between you and rest of us is nobody but you will feel
"soul is washed clean there" because it was you who believes whatever
"gratifying" and
"uplifting" is like religions, religious experience and religious practice. It's too late to deny that you are the one who believes that
"Religion is like sex." or
"Religion is like sh*ting!" based on your logic, your understanding of religion, and keeps telling us
"that is a statement made by many others." Trying so hard to impose your logic and your understanding of religions on others only makes you even more pathetic.
"The communists would never have won over the KMT as the KMT army was far superior to the Mao's peasant army."
What do you mean by
"win over"? Do you mean the Communist won over the KMT as friend during the war between 1946 to 1949? I assume you meant
"defeat". Please keep in mind next time that
"win over" and
"defeat" are quite opposite in meaning..
You are now desperate and showing your ignorance again...
You need to read the history of that period. Here are some of the reading points for you to start with.
- The war between the Communist and the KMT during 46 to 49 was not for or about democracy in China at all. Instead it's one of the bloodiest civil wars on earth and more and more people find the war was not justified. It makes your argument totally irrelevant to the subject (improving democracy).
- The civil war was about Mao's personal dream to be an emperor, his hunger for power and he did not care much about how many Chinese would die during the civil war. It had nothing to do with democracy.
- Your example was about army fighting army militarily, not about citizens fighting government peacefully. By that example you are inciting the bare-handed citizens fighting government and army. You can see how desperate your argument is.
- Do you know how many millions of Chinese died during that war? Anyone who has
BASIC understanding of democracy will not even think of risking the loss of that many Chinese lives. You are obviously lack of
BASIC understanding of democracy and the modern Chinese history. What's worse is you don't seem to care about how many millions of Chinese will die when you incite that bare-handed Chinese should start a war against Chinese government and Chinese armies, or they are as guilty or evil as the regime.
"civil disobedience"
Glad to see you mentioned it. I am not sure if you understand the concept because it's a quite opposite approach from the
"violent or military actions" that you have been so vehemently inciting for some time now that Chinese people should always take at all costs, otherwise they are evil too.
"If you do not stand up against evil, you become evil"
Are you saying that there was no difference between ordinary German people and Hitler. If your answer is yes or no, please explain, will you? When you explain, please try to use your brain this time...
Let me repeat what I said in the very beginning "Improving democracy in China is like many things in life about
"doing the right thing at the right time". I hope you will understand when you grow older...
Since you have been so vehemently inciting that Chinese people should take violent actions or start a war against the government, it makes me wonder who give you the right or what credentials you have to preach Chinese people to do so? If I remember correctly, you were the coward and the chicken that ran away from Tian An Meng Square. Isn't it a bit ironic and amusing to see such a person preaching so vehemently the crap? To save people's time as well as mine, let me summarize the kid game you have been trying to play and trying to manipulate, that is "Chinese people should take violent actions or start a war against the government, or shut up." Of course the key point is "shut up"...
By the way, my 286 wants to send her regards to you. 7 years, what a pathetic character...LOL