最初由 roaring mouse 发布
去问问你爷爷? He was fighting the japanese. He was betrayed by a christian chinese to the Japanese. Anytime, u can find people that are good or bad.
去问问你爸爸? He was fighting the US in Korea and he was tortured during the cultural revolution. do u think we are worse than those in the cultural revolution. country in chaos, torture, jail without reason, kicked out of schools because parents were considered reactionary.
the world is changing, so change with the world. do not be pessimistic. today's china is better than yesterday's china. there will be new problems but they are no excuses for your saying the past is better than the present
"do u think we are worse than those in the cultural revolution. country in chaos, torture, jail without reason, kicked out of schools because parents were considered reactionary."
Good question. But what if someone asks you who is responsible for the disaster, chaos, killing and torturing in the Culture Revolution in the first place? And not just the Culture Revolution, who's responsible for many other horrible events happened to millions of Chinese for the last close to 60 years? The ordinary Chinese people? Or the government?
"today's china is better than yesterday's china."
Better living or progress for whom? For what percentage of people? At what cost? environmentally? morally? socially? and culturally? At what expense for majority of people? To save people's time on reading and mine on writing, let me just elaborate a little bit on the last question that is "at what expense for majority of people?"
For 70 to 80 percent of Chinese mostly farmers, 农民工s and those living in the small towns in the countryside or rural areas, some of the realities of the "better life" and "progress" they are facing are as following.
- Income level. I read an investigative report called "Investigative Report on Chinese Farmers" published in one of the reputable Chinese magazines a couple of years ago. The report was done based on a five-year study and research in An Hui province. It said some farmers after one year hardworking and after the deduction from heavy taxes and other costs etc., they ended up having only 5 Chinese Yuan left for the Chinese Spring Festival. We all know how much 5 Yuan can buy these days. You tell me if after having worked your butt off for one year with only 5 Yuan in your hand for your family when Spring Festival or Christams approaching, you will think it's a better life or a progress for your family after 60 years the one party government in power?
- Medical insurance. There have no or close to nothing med insurance for these people. It means there's nothing they can do but wait for death if they have serious illness. For less serious illness they still can't afford the hospital treatment and sky-rocking medicine price, many of them have to rely on the luck of the strength and the youth of their bodies.
- Social insurance. There's no social insurance for most of these people, which means if they do not have a job then they are completely on their own live or dying.
- Basic education opportunity. Many of you probably have already read more terrible reports or stories about how difficult for kids to get education in countryside or rural areas. The 农民工's kids are facing the similar difficulties. You probably also know how low the percentage of the government education budget compared to other countries for country kids.
I assume you live in Canada. Do you think it's fair or a progress that you have been paying the same amount of tax when buying your clothes, shoes or other daily stuff, but you (just because you happen to be in the bottom of the society) have been striped of the above benefits that you are entitled to just as everybody else?
When we do comparisons, we not only need to compare historically or vertically, but more importantly we need to compare horizontally. Also, not only compare those rich and famous well to dos, but more importantly compare those that constitute the majority in the bottom of a society. In other words, if you really want to compare, you should compare
the majority Chinese (farmers, 农民工s and others alike) who live at lower economic bracket with similar groups of people in other counties
during the same 60 year period, and see how the foreign groups have been doing in their economic improvement, education, social welfare (med and social insurance), environmental changes, unnatural death rate, index of personal satisfactions, their human rights and so on. The comparison factors can go much longer. I think a comparison of such kind would be much closer to the reality.
I wouldn't be surprised to hear the Mr. Mouse may roar that a Chinese with electricity, running water and a TV set lives a much better life than any kings and queens in the world several hundred years ago (because none of those gadgets were available back then). Therefore the government is the best in the world to make it citizens live better than kings and queens. But if you compare horizontally, well, the picture would probably tell a different story.