为什么塔利班明明最有害于阿富汗人民，却具有雄厚的民意基础？这就是人民普遍德智低下、社会共业极度恶化的结果。反儒社会，极权主义容易得民心；伊教社会，极端主义乃至恐怖主义容易得民心。
在这两种社会，政府不坏到一定程度都站不住脚。
阿富汗主要宗教是伊教，穆斯林占99%。这就是塔利班厚实的社会基础。这也意味着，在阿富汗，无论什么好制度，都是无法扎根、不可持续的，即使勉强推行，也会迅速恶化而失败。这是自绝于自由、自绝于文明、自绝于良制良法的社会。
拜登的阿富汗政策辩护说得很好
- 主题发起人 ert0000
- 开始时间
为什么塔利班明明最有害于阿富汗人民，却具有雄厚的民意基础？这就是人民普遍德智低下、社会共业极度恶化的结果。反儒社会，极权主义容易得民心；伊教社会，极端主义乃至恐怖主义容易得民心。
在这两种社会，政府不坏到一定程度都站不住脚。
阿富汗主要宗教是伊教，穆斯林占99%。这就是塔利班厚实的社会基础。这也意味着，在阿富汗，无论什么好制度，都是无法扎根、不可持续的，即使勉强推行，也会迅速恶化而失败。这是自绝于自由、自绝于文明、自绝于良制良法的社会。
你凭啥替阿富汗人做主呢？
- 注册
- 2005-12-07
- 消息
- 21,757
- 荣誉分数
- 5,877
- 声望点数
- 373
殖民还有好的例子？ 说来听听？ 之前有人回帖说香港。那我就说香港， 仔细看香港在殖民地这1，2百年，49年前，说繁荣程度，香港非但远远赶不上上海，和当时的天津相比都不一定能赢。看看49年前英国人给香港人民主了么？看看当时选举是怎么选的？
香港真正的繁荣时期恰恰是老G掌权的2段时间，而这2段时间，恰恰是各种地缘政治的产物。第一阶段改革开放前，老毛为了给自己政权一个可以贸易的窗口而没收回香港，如果老毛真想收，英国人还得滚蛋，看看渡江战役前，老毛就敢和英国军舰对轰，英国怂了。79年前香港经济的繁荣，还不是借着老G特意留下的窗口？ 如果香港放在别的地方，还会这么发么？
第二段时间就是改革开放后，香港整个繁荣更是依赖中国的市场。
到油管查一下，几百年殖民中，英国从印度掠夺了多少资产，黄金，还是一个英国著名的传媒做的。。。。
billwanhua
本站元老
- 注册
- 2005-07-07
- 消息
- 17,157
- 荣誉分数
- 5,661
- 声望点数
- 373
起码香港人民比较认命，没有反抗。
你这样看待问题，我只能表示无语。说多了，肯定让你不舒服。相信你自己说的吧，挺好。
billwanhua
本站元老
- 注册
- 2005-07-07
- 消息
- 17,157
- 荣誉分数
- 5,661
- 声望点数
- 373
那是翻译的问题，imperial不仅仅帝国还有皇帝的意思，拿破仑4世就是His Imperial Highness The Prince Imperial 皇储殿下。
另外东西方文化不同，很多词语不能翻译，conservative保守党,翻译成中文就是贬义.
总体来说，殖民是贬义词，西方文化也是这么认为的，可以Google ：
is colonial positive or negative word
能发现很多
电影avatar也是反对殖民的故事
另外，colonist是中性，包含殖民者和被殖民的人，
殖民地移民；殖民地開拓者
a settler in or inhabitant of a colony
而colonizer是殖民者
最后编辑:
1). Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC)
CIBC means an empire of commerce, or an empire of the commercial banks, not an empire of the states ( country).
The concept of colonialism is closely linked to that of imperialism, which is the policy or ethos of using power and influence to control another nation or people that underlies colonialism.
3). Harm more than benefits
Colonial governments invested in infrastructure and trade and disseminated medical and technological knowledge. In some cases, they encouraged literacy, the adoption of Western human rights standards, and sowed the seeds for democratic institutions and systems of government. Some former colonies, like Ghana, experienced a rise in nutrition and health with colonial rule, and colonial European settlement has been linked to some development gains.
However, coercion and forced assimilation often accompanied those gains, and scholars still debate colonialism’s many legacies. Colonialism’s impacts include environmental degradation, the spread of disease, economic instability, ethnic rivalries, and human rights violations, and genocide or culture genocide—issues that can long outlast one group’s colonial rule.
Beware of some marginal benefits of colonialism being exploited by some far-right-wing politicians and even academics. However, no one dares openly to promote colonialism in today's world.
Reference: Colonialism facts and information
CIBC means an empire of commerce, or an empire of the commercial banks, not an empire of the states ( country).
2). Colonialism
Colonialism is defined as “control by one power over a dependent area or people.” It occurs when one nation subjugates another, conquering its population and exploiting it, often while forcing its own language and cultural values upon its people.
The concept of colonialism is closely linked to that of imperialism, which is the policy or ethos of using power and influence to control another nation or people that underlies colonialism.
3). Harm more than benefits
Colonial governments invested in infrastructure and trade and disseminated medical and technological knowledge. In some cases, they encouraged literacy, the adoption of Western human rights standards, and sowed the seeds for democratic institutions and systems of government. Some former colonies, like Ghana, experienced a rise in nutrition and health with colonial rule, and colonial European settlement has been linked to some development gains.
However, coercion and forced assimilation often accompanied those gains, and scholars still debate colonialism’s many legacies. Colonialism’s impacts include environmental degradation, the spread of disease, economic instability, ethnic rivalries, and human rights violations, and genocide or culture genocide—issues that can long outlast one group’s colonial rule.
Beware of some marginal benefits of colonialism being exploited by some far-right-wing politicians and even academics. However, no one dares openly to promote colonialism in today's world.
Reference: Colonialism facts and information
- 注册
- 2004-12-11
- 消息
- 18,918
- 荣誉分数
- 4,257
- 声望点数
- 373
卖着热狗 心系党国
