[闲聊] 存在？死亡？那个更好？你会选择哪个？
- 主题发起人 某某
- 开始时间
Re: Re: Re: [闲聊] 存在？死亡？那个更好？你会选择哪个？
当事人没有选择能力只说明他/她没有能力行使自己的权利, 不等于说她/他就应此丧失了这一权利, 更不等于说其他人可以代其行使本属于他/她的这一权利.
重申一下, 这是社会是否尊重一个人的生存权的问题, 而不是关于这个具体的人是否死了对自己, 家人和社会更省事的问题. 即使那位当事人心里想结束生命, 如果她没有能力做到的话(或者连想的能力都没有), 其他任何人都无权代其结束本属于她的生命.
用自己对生命意义的标准去裁判他人是否该结束生命才是真正的武断. 而基于自己的裁判将结束他人生命之想法付诸实施的行为不是谋杀又是什么?
社会如果不恪守对生存权的无条件的尊重这一底线, 不是我危言耸听, 将会有很多人的生命陷于无保障的境地. 尤其是那些智障, 年老多病的弱势群体的人士迟早会面临生存权由别人来操纵的灾难.
当事人没有选择能力只说明他/她没有能力行使自己的权利, 不等于说她/他就应此丧失了这一权利, 更不等于说其他人可以代其行使本属于他/她的这一权利.
重申一下, 这是社会是否尊重一个人的生存权的问题, 而不是关于这个具体的人是否死了对自己, 家人和社会更省事的问题. 即使那位当事人心里想结束生命, 如果她没有能力做到的话(或者连想的能力都没有), 其他任何人都无权代其结束本属于她的生命.
用自己对生命意义的标准去裁判他人是否该结束生命才是真正的武断. 而基于自己的裁判将结束他人生命之想法付诸实施的行为不是谋杀又是什么?
社会如果不恪守对生存权的无条件的尊重这一底线, 不是我危言耸听, 将会有很多人的生命陷于无保障的境地. 尤其是那些智障, 年老多病的弱势群体的人士迟早会面临生存权由别人来操纵的灾难.
Broken Arrow
新手上路
- 注册
- 2002-10-30
- 消息
- 261
- 荣誉分数
- 0
- 声望点数
- 0
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: [闲聊] 存在？死亡？那个更好？你会选择哪个？
haha, I see. Then let's say your second 5-minute miracle comes in another 15 years. What would you do?
最初由 Kent以东首帅哥 发布
Should one miracle happen, I would count on the 2nd miracle and even the 3rd.
haha, I see. Then let's say your second 5-minute miracle comes in another 15 years. What would you do?
Broken Arrow
新手上路
- 注册
- 2002-10-30
- 消息
- 261
- 荣誉分数
- 0
- 声望点数
- 0
Re: Re: Re: Re: [闲聊] 存在？死亡？那个更好？你会选择哪个？
I agree with your point that no one shall use his/her own judgement on life and force upon others.
In this case, court doesn't say Schiavo should die, rather court believe Schiavo wants to die. And if you don't believe, it is OK. No one can say for sure you are wrong or right. And that's why this case is so controversial...
Now if a person clearly states his/her will before he/she is incapacitated, that he/she wants to die when encountering irreversible pain or suffering from illness or others such as this permanent vegitative state, then I think he/she has the right to die, and it is only humane to help.
I agree with your point that no one shall use his/her own judgement on life and force upon others.
In this case, court doesn't say Schiavo should die, rather court believe Schiavo wants to die. And if you don't believe, it is OK. No one can say for sure you are wrong or right. And that's why this case is so controversial...
Now if a person clearly states his/her will before he/she is incapacitated, that he/she wants to die when encountering irreversible pain or suffering from illness or others such as this permanent vegitative state, then I think he/she has the right to die, and it is only humane to help.
Re: Re: [闲聊] 存在？死亡？那个更好？你会选择哪个？
For the entire existence of mankind, we have struggled with the question, "What happens after death?" Our answer to this dilemma has great implications for our life here on earth. Although many avoid the issue, we must sooner or later address the question. There are many competing answers to this question.
For the entire existence of mankind, we have struggled with the question, "What happens after death?" Our answer to this dilemma has great implications for our life here on earth. Although many avoid the issue, we must sooner or later address the question. There are many competing answers to this question.
Atheists believe that at death one ceases to exist. There is no afterlife or eternal soul that continues in eternity. All there is to look forward to is our inevitable death, the future death of mankind, and the universe. It is in the face of this future that the atheist must seek to find meaning and purpose for his own existence.
The Eastern and New Age religions that hold to a pantheistic worldview teach that one goes through an endless cycle of reincarnation until the cycle is broken and the person becomes one with the divine. What form a person becomes in the next life depends on the quality of life lived in the previous life. When one unites with the divine, he ceases to exist as an individual, but becomes part of the divine life force, like a drop of water returning to the ocean.
Islam teaches that at the end of history, God will judge the works of all men. Those whose good deeds outweigh their bad deeds will enter into paradise. The rest will be consigned to hell. The Koran teaches that in paradise men will be drinking wine and entertained by heavenly maidens and that they may take several of these maidens for their wives.
You're not alone if you find yourself honestly unconvinced about life after death. But keep in mind that Jesus promised to give divine help to those who want to know the truth so as to surrender to it. He said, "If anyone chooses to do God's will, he will find out whether My teaching comes from God or whether I speak on My own"
