Minto购房悲剧----从走进Minto售房中心那一刻降临

[闲得慌]

买房子当然不是，但Minto给楼主选择的时候，楼主冒着没收6万6的危险，拒绝了Minto的offer。这就是赌博。

你同意买房不是赌博，那很好。

问题是Minto不诚实，欺骗顾客，在被顾客揭露的后，又为客户设立赌局，现在LZ拒绝参与这个赌局。

 

[forward]

Inventory home was already discussed in May

因为有了新的爆料：BDW买的实际上是INVENTORY HOME。我觉得当初很多人支持她抗议时，不知道这个情况。这个新线索直接影响到BDW举牌的胜算率。

The inventory home and "sold as is" clause were already fully debated and awared in May. Nothing new is debated here. The issue should be moved on how to negotiate a deal with help of lawyer. What is the expectation for BDW with the understanding of the full deposit return is the least acceptable option for Minto?

BDW has done the standing protest for 2 or 3 weeks in various locations. is the situation getting better?

In BuildHome board, someone already refer a lawyer specialized in these cases. I actually think Riven should close this thread like Build Home adminsitrator did last weekend.

 

[uglyducking]

你错了，BDW刚开始发这个贴的时候，我就注意到了这个贴，而且估计到她会把这事情往民族主义上引。

I was just guessing

i was focusing on a different direction while you were predicting '估计到她会把这事情往民族主义上引'

 

[uglyducking]

你错了，BDW刚开始发这个贴的时候，我就注意到了这个贴，而且估计到她会把这事情往民族主义上引。

楼主的第一贴发表于：2011-10-20, 14:07
我的第一个回帖发表于：2011-10-20, 16:00

那时楼主还没有发表“中华民族文化复兴论”。

i was talking about bdw's post from May, not her updated story in Oct.

 

[uglyducking]

in May, already lots of questions raised regarding if there's "sold as is" clause in the contract. it seemed to me that there's no such statement otherwise there's no argument points in this matter at all.

The inventory home and "sold as is" clause were already fully debated and awared in May. Nothing new is debated here. The issue should be moved on how to negotiate a deal with help of lawyer. What is the expectation for BDW with the understanding of the full deposit return is the least acceptable option for Minto?

BDW has done the standing protest for 2 or 3 weeks in various locations. is the situation getting better?

In BuildHome board, someone already refer a lawyer specialized in these cases. I actually think Riven should close this thread like Build Home adminsitrator did last weekend.

 

[CanMa2011]

Are you sure this is new information? I have always been under the impression that she bought inventory home, from reading her original post here. The date of signing agreement and the closing date are too close. Of course I mean from this THIS original post, not from May.

But the main issue is: did she know that? It seems to me that she never acknowledged anywhere that it was inventory home. She had at several places indicated that she thought Minto would build a house according to the floor plan but it turned out wrong.

Even the No.1 supporter had this impression:

好像LZ几次在帖子里提到她买的不是inventory home。现在不知道原始买房合同里到底是怎么写的。

 

[mimi_ge]

这话流传很久了，也叫”魔鬼隐藏于细节中“。

first time heard 细节是魔鬼 but it's so true
bdw is responsible for the current result, same as MINTO and her lawyer. the question is, is the mistake worth for $66k as penalty only on bdw herself while minto gained $5k+$66k as reward?

 

[viper99]

因为有了新的爆料：BDW买的实际上是INVENTORY HOME。我觉得当初很多人支持她抗议时，不知道这个情况。这个新线索直接影响到BDW举牌的胜算率。

虽然BDW没说，但一开始时就有人提出那一定是INVENTORY HOME了

 

[uglyducking]

only heard 'cong1 dong4 shi4' 魔鬼

这话流传很久了，也叫”魔鬼隐藏于细节中“。

 

[xiaoyoyo]

虽然BDW没说，但一开始时就有人提出那一定是INVENTORY HOME了

我就是其中一个。。。
因为只要是买过新房的人都知道正常的流程，如果不是inventory home
，lot开盘的时候是可以选房型的。如果地基都打好了框架也搭了，那肯定是inventory home。
房价比list price不低不能说明问题，因为很多inventory home有很多升级，价格都比当时list出来的价格高

不过楼主坚持说合同里没写是inventory home
除了她自己和minto，我们都没法知道合同的细节


还是挺同情楼主的，错过了减少损失的最佳机会

 

[mimi_ge]

冲动是魔鬼，细节也是魔鬼，通常指在断案过程中，很小的细节，能让整个案件大白于天下。tvb电视剧经常说。
就拿bdw不承认，也不否认inventory，这是细节1.
律师关键时刻弃他而去，必有原因，因为从未听说此类荒谬事件，这是细节2.
所以西人说的很对，minto也有他们的版本，兼听则明，否则就太simple啦。
但关键是minto也没有官方版本，所以才有我们这些闲人说三道四，说了也白说，不说白不说。

only heard 'cong1 dong4 shi4' 魔鬼

 

[forward]

That is exactly Minto's point

in May, already lots of questions raised regarding if there's "sold as is" clause in the contract. it seemed to me that there's no such statement otherwise there's no argument points in this matter at all.

For Minto, it thought the home in question is an inventory home and it is sold as is. Otherwise, it contradicts itself -- Do you see a brand new home to be build is "sold-as-is" from large new home builders like M, U, M or R? In other word, buyers will getting a home without any change option ? inventory home is "sold-as-is" unless the buyer is willing to pay much more to change it (like mimi_ge's said).

Now Minto might realize late that there was a mistake (such as price and area) and offered BDW $10K deduction like other inventory home. For me, it is a clear clause.

 

[councilor]

I agree about '通过网友回贴，给Minto施加压力', that was also a part of reason i helped to post a thread in another forum.

I guess you might not even notice about bdw's orignal post until you saw the “中华民族文化复兴论”

你错了，BDW刚开始发这个贴的时候，我就注意到了这个贴，而且估计到她会把这事情往民族主义上引。

楼主的第一贴发表于：2011-10-20, 14:07
我的第一个回帖发表于：2011-10-20, 16:00

那时楼主还没有发表“中华民族文化复兴论”。

i was talking about bdw's post from May, not her updated story in Oct.

以前那个贴，我还真的没有注意，好像那个贴也不在主坛上。

 

[闲得慌]

Even the No.1 supporter had this impression:

退一步说，即使合同里说明是inventory, 也不能你买的是CRV inventory，给你的是CIVIC的inventory。

 

[uglyducking]

以前那个贴，我还真的没有注意，好像那个贴也不在主坛上。

in 我爱我家